Transcript 0:00 The future of Bitcoin is probably likely now to be characterized more by lower volatility, passive bids by wealth advisors into ETFs. Like, that's a good thing. 0:09 I mean, that's the reason I think you've seen the whales, some whales, not all, but some OG whales distributing here is not because they're bearish on Bitcoin's future, but simply because they can. 0:18 The market is so much more liquid and bigger than it has been in the past. 0:22 Perhaps the era of ten x, hundred x, thousand x is over for Bitcoin, and that it's entering a new maturity phase where it looks a lot more like a stable but growing asset. 0:31 A lot to compete with this year, and Bitcoin just didn't deliver the returns necessary to, to keep it in the front of every investor's minds. 0:39 I think that can change, and we're obviously long, and I haven't put out my year-end twenty-six call yet. Uh, I'm not quite prepared to do that, but I think suffice to say it will be higher. 0:49 Welcome back to the Blockspace podcast. I've got Alex Thorn, Head of Research at Galaxy Digital. Alex, welcome to the show. Thanks for having me, Charlie. Big fan of the show and, and great to be here. Yeah. 1:00 You know, I've had, uh, a number of the Galaxy Research folks. I had Will, I had Zach, and I'm completing my infinity gauntlet with you here. 1:09 And I have it-- I have half a mind to try to talk about stable coins 'cause, you know, there's, there's not a lot of Bitcoiners, I think, who have like a sophisticated understanding of stable coins, myself included. 1:21 And so I wanna have like a Bitcoiner to Bitcoiner chat about sales. But before that, as of right now on Monday, uh, the, the-- this pod comes out Wednesday. 1:29 As of right now, the government is still shut down, and I think maybe this could be an interesting place to kick it off. How much is the government shutdown affecting Bitcoin price? 1:37 And now that we may have a light at the end of the tunnel, what's your take? I don't think it's affected it that much. I think the October tenth leverage wipeout, as I've been calling it, definitely affected it more. 1:49 Um, I think competition this year from AI, from stable coins, from, um, nuclear, from, from general high-performance compute and data center investments, and gold has been more of a headwind for Bitcoin than even, even recently than, than the shutdown. 2:06 I do wonder though, it does appear that the Senate, as we record on, on November tenth here on Monday, that the Senate is about to vote, uh, or may have just voted to actually advance their package to open the government, but it does have to go back to the House 'cause they didn't actually vote on the clean version the House already passed. 2:23 Assuming it does get passed by the House and signed by the president and signed, and the shutdown ends, I do wonder if perhaps while the shutdown might not have been uniquely bearish for Bitcoin and crypto, perhaps the reopen could be bullish. 2:38 Um, since we feel kind of... I mean, I don't know, as we write on Monday here, the, the, the cryptos and the stocks and the gold are all rallying, presumably mostly on optimism around the reopening. Yeah. 2:50 Um, it feels like crypto and, and Bitcoin's at pretty low, like, or nearly bottom sentiment. Uh, you know, the, the fear and greed index and all that stuff's low. 2:58 So presumably any big positive government catalyst could help and could be a tailwind. 3:03 And you guys actually recently, Galaxy Research, uh, revised their end-of-year, y'all's end-of-year price prediction from, I believe, a hundred and eighty K Bitcoin to like one hundred and twenty thousand dollar Bitcoin. 3:15 Uh, I mean, what's behind that? I know you explained it, but kinda what's behind that and, um- Yeah... also a hundred twenty K Bitcoin, that's, that's still great. 3:22 That's, that's still doing great from where we are today. So, uh, what's behind it? That's so nice of you to say 'cause people have been calling me a dirty bear. 3:29 They said, "Well, if you're not gonna be-" They don't know who you are. You've been in this game forever. 3:32 [laughs] "If you're not gonna keep one eighty-five and you're gonna say one twenty, why don't you just sell all your Bitcoin?" Some people said. And I was like, "First of all, I'm not gonna sell my Bitcoin. 3:40 I'm very long Bitcoin. And second of all, that's still a twenty percent rise in six weeks. This is through the end of the year." 3:46 In fact, if anything, and I told this to our clients and counterparties when I sent them that note last week, I should have revised it lower sooner. 3:53 I, I think that, that, like I said, that October tenth wipeout really sort of catalyzed the, the need to update. 3:59 But also keep in mind, that one eighty-five year-end twenty twenty-five call, I made that on December thirty-first, twenty twenty-four, so a month and a half after the president won his re-election. 4:09 This was a period between, you know, November fifth and January twentieth last year when the number one trade in the world was long Bitcoin, okay? Like, across every asset class. 4:20 And that was because everybody knew that the president was gonna have a very pro-crypto agenda, but there were no specifics yet. We didn't even have the nominees for things like the SEC yet, right? 4:30 So we just knew there was a giant pile of positive catalysts that were coming, and we didn't know what they were, and, and it was all hope and no substance, and everyone just knew they were meant to be long. 4:40 And so they were, and that was a very bullish time. A lot of people put out targets. 4:45 Um, I, I posted at the time in like, in January of th-- of this year, but shortly thereafter, like, I, I was in like the low, middle to low range of, of like very public Bitcoiners targets at one eighty-five. 4:55 People were calling for two hundred, two fifty. Um, so, uh, that one eighty-five was a call I made over a, you know, about a year ago after the president's re-election. 5:04 I probably should have lowered it sooner, but I still haven't seen any of those other people really lower theirs. Yeah. So I feel pretty safe. 5:11 Um, you know, there, there was a range of factors, I, I, I said before, like just narrative speculation, a, a narrative sort of primacy and, and prioritization in the markets, the broad risk markets. 5:22 And Bitcoin is a global macro asset. It's traded by people who trade other asset classes in size now. It's not just hobbyists, it's not early adopting speculators, right? 5:32 So it matters what big investors are thinking about. And while it was the number one trade at one point with, you know, MicroStrategy, remember last year, it was... 5:43 that was like the biggest story in all of Wall Street, is what Michael Saylor did last year. And long Bitcoin was the trade everyone was meant to be in, and it pushed us up to all-time highs and, uh, again and again. 5:53 But over this year, that's just changed, right? Gold itself is, you know, up, what? Thirty percent on the year. Hold on, let me just pull it here up here. Yeah. Um, yeah. Those are big.Yeah. 6:05 Gold is up, uh, fifty-seven percent as we write year to date, whereas Bitcoin's up a meager twelve, right? S&P's up twenty-one. Sorry, S&P is up fifteen. [chuckles] Nasdaq's up seventeen. 6:18 Sorry, I got like it's a, it's a big grid I gotta look at. Yeah. I'm like trying to track it over. But again, S&P and Nasdaq performing better as we speak year to date. Gold way better, right? 6:28 And, and so like Mag Seven, AI hype and, and investment, data centers, HPC, even some nuclear stocks, a bunch of quantum stocks, gold. One of the- Yeah. 6:38 I mean, you could be long one of the most conservative assets in the world and have made fifty-seven percent this year. Yeah. 6:44 Like Bitcoin is at best like, and crypto, like maybe like seventh to tenth in the list of trades that the world is sort of looking at this year. 6:53 And that sort of narrative slip, like by not reaching continuous like crazy moon new highs this year, it just sort of lost some attention. And I think that that's largely... I would say that's the biggest headwind. 7:05 I think part of the reason it didn't is, is also because of significant whale selling, like huge distribution. Bullish though, because it was into large absorption. 7:15 Um, other factors too, in fact, frankly, like stable coin investment. If you look at the- Yeah... 7:19 venture space in crypto, it's been dominated by this year by like fintech-type investments, payments, cross-border payments, stable coin L-ones, right? 7:29 Like very small investment in like Bitcoin startups, although Bitcoin's always lagged on the VC side. Um, so I just... 7:35 A lot to compete with this year, and Bitcoin just didn't deliver the returns necessary to, to keep it in the front of every investor's minds. I think that can change and will change. 7:45 We're obviously long, medium and long term, and have a... You know, I haven't put out my year-end '26 call yet. Uh, I'm not quite prepared to do that, but I think suffice to say it will be higher. 7:55 I'm, I'm of similar mind. I'll, I'll just double tap on this. 7:58 I mean, like, so yeah, we saw hotter investments, AI, AI-related, everything downstream of that, gold, some macro instability, although it just depends on who you talk to. 8:09 Um, what does it take for Bitcoin to regain the belle of the ball, the darling trade? 8:16 Like, what do you think, what do you think has to happen for it to get back up to the, one of the more desirable top two or three trades? 8:23 I mean, I think you need the headlines of like nation state, you know, form-formulates or launches strategic Bitcoin reserve. I think you need giant pension. 8:32 I mean, we're at such a high level now that like, you know, three of the four world's biggest custody banks have launched or have announced they're launching Bitcoin custody, right? Like that used to... 8:40 If you said that in twenty eighteen, we'd probably rip like twenty or thirty percent, right? 8:44 [chuckles] Like now, like the bar is so high because Bitcoin's such a big established, m-more mature asset that, well, the, for big shocking catalysts, they have to be even bigger. That being... 8:56 And I, and I think you'll get those, right? It, it's unclear when, and not just generally, but even, say from the US Treasury. Presumably, we are still yet to find out something about the SBR. 9:07 They are working on it, you know? Yeah. I don't, I don't think you're gonna... I, I, I don't, I'm-- and I said last year that they would hold but not buy. That was my prediction for '25. Yeah. That's been right so far. 9:17 I-- yeah, but they also haven't really come out and said how much they hold, and I know why. 9:22 It's very d-- like actually, if you just ChatGPT, like explain like civil asset forfeiture federal statutes, really not like that clear that the government can even legally c-recognizer the Bitcoin into its own SBR. 9:35 But, so there's legal issues. I think something like that, though, like could, could create a step function where Bitcoin really takes the like limelight and, and is the number one again. 9:44 But I would say the future of Bitcoin is probably likely now to be characterized more by lower volatility, passive bids, by wealth advisors into ETFs. Like that, that's a good thing. 9:55 I mean, that's the reason I think you've seen the whales, some whales, not all, but some OG whales distributing here is not because they're bearish on Bitcoin's future, but simply because they can. 10:05 The market is so much liq-- more liquid and bigger than it has been in the past. And a bigger liquid market, that means you can enter with more... 10:13 When, when, when volatility is lower, you can take a bigger position size. That's when you might start to see like pensions and endowments with really big allocations. So, um, it might not be... 10:23 I mean, I said, [chuckles] this might be why people call me a dirty bear. 10:26 [chuckles] I said, perhaps the era of ten x, hundred x, thousand x is over for Bitcoin, and that it's entering a new maturity phase where it looks a lot more like a stable but growing asset. 10:37 So, and, and I, I think, you know, and, and that's just kind of what winning looks like. I don't know what people expected. It's a lot harder to double a two trillion dollar asset than a two hundred billion dollar asset. 10:47 It's a lot harder. Oh, yeah. It takes a lot more capital. A lot of people forget. Yeah. I mean, roll the clock back just three years. A year and a day ago, FTX declared bankruptcy, and it was like a sentiment bottom. 10:59 You were in the middle of this at the time. In fact, yesterday you tweeted about it as some great reflection, some great reflective thoughts. 11:06 Like, people forget how dramatically the entire narrative can change and evolve in just a matter of three years. Um, so yeah, I guess maybe the last question on this is like, you, you mentioned this era of comparative, 11:24 uh, boringness, if you will, begins to behave more like a normal, uh, good per- well-performing asset. Is this the institutional bid? Like, 11:34 um, you know, what would invalidate that thesis and, uh, yeah, what do you, you know, what do you think in three to five years from now? Oh, man. 11:44 I mean, I, I, it's hard to know, and I, I don't like to perform like, you know, model-based price predictions. I, I think whether it's like discounted cash flow or something else, I mean, partly the reason is, um, it... 11:56 No oneFrom a financial modeling standpoint, nobody still agrees upon what Bitcoin actually is and, and I, nor do I. So for example, some people say you can do a DCF model on anything. I totally disagree with that. 12:07 [chuckles] I don't think you can. You end up with absurd ranges like, you know, three to three thousand dollars or like, you know, you know, one hundred K to five million, and I just don't see those as useful. 12:18 Um, I, I do think it, it will become used more broadly as a portfolio, uh, hedging asset, a debasement hedge, uh, a risk off store of value asset, and in that sense, I do like comparing it to gold. 12:30 I think Bitcoin has peaked at like eleven or twelve percent of gold's market cap, uh, during the last bull market. Um, I, I would like to see that get to twenty or thirty in the next five years or so. 12:41 I think it's possible. You know, and, and I should say like, I mean, Bitcoin is highly scarce. 12:46 Any meaningful uptick in adoption could absolutely create upside volatility that doesn't look like the slow mature grind I'm talking about. 12:53 Um, I'm just sort of saying I think that's my base case, and it surely can be characterized by rips up and dumps down. Like it's not gonna be... Even right now, I mean, we're down, we've been down, what? 13:04 Twenty plus percent from the all-time high. Yeah. That's a meaningful... In fact, that's bear market territory when you think about like tradit-- the way financial analysts talk about traditional equities. 13:14 Um, so I mean, I, I think it will still be volatile, but I think, you know, it's reasonable to think we're in the two, three hundred K range in, in five years, I think just back of the napkin. 13:24 Um, and, and I think that'll be characterized just by much more wide ownership. Think about this. The, the, the supply, the old supply that's been distributing to new entrants is fixed. 13:36 That's a fi-- there's a finite amount of old supply overhang, but there's theoretically an unlimited demand, uh, upside or amount of demand, right? And so, um, this is good. I mean, where did you want people to sell? 13:48 You want 'em to create a head win at a hundred and fifty? I mean, it was gonna happen, right? Yeah. Like, it's better to clear, clear some of this out now. 13:54 I think the fact that we're literally doing the meme of Bitcoin dumps to a hundred thousand. [chuckles] We're literally doing the meme. Oh, CZ was tweeting about... 14:02 If you go back, there's a tweet for that CZ had from like twenty twenty. It was like, "Sometime in the future, Bitcoin crashes to a hundred K, and everyone's in shambles." Yeah. Yeah. We're doing it. 14:11 And that's kind of what's happened. We crashed to a hundred. The fear and greed index was like the lowest it's ever been, as if we were in like a, a devastating bear market, right? Yeah. 14:21 So now part of that is just 'cause like so much absorption has happened. 14:25 I think James Check has done a really good job with this data this year, but one of the things he's been saying and tracking is that the average network cost basis, like the realized price basically, is ninety-five, ninety-six K. 14:36 So like ha- more than half the network theoretically is underwater below ninety-six. And that, that just says, wow, you know, one, that should be a line for the bulls to hold. 14:46 And I would say near term, if we go below there, I start to get concerned about the status of this bull market. 14:52 Still to me, this looks like softness and, but, but well available for a continuation of this bull market at these levels. Below there, it gets a little dicey. 15:00 But the other positive way to look at that is there's an enormous amount of demand to own Bitcoin and buy Bitcoin over ninety-six K. There-- Like an enormous amount. 15:07 Most of the Bitcoins on the network have moved on chain at prices that were higher than that. 15:13 So that, I think that's really good acceptance of Bitcoin as a big, much more valuable asset, and that's, you know, an important step onto it being used as a debasement hedge by, you know, the types of entities that really need debasement at scale, right? 15:27 I mean, individuals need debasement protection, but so do like multi-hundred billion dollar investment firms. Um, and I think, you know, it, it'll play a role there. You know, this is just another bump along the ride. 15:40 I prob-- You know, we'll probably be on here in two, three years- Yeah... Charlie, talking about the panic that is ensuing because Bitcoin's crashed to two hundred K, right? Yeah. It feels like that. 15:50 We're gonna have- We've been around long enough to know that's possible. Yeah. It's likely. We're gonna keep having this conversation forever. It's gonna be the same conversation, higher prices every year. 15:58 [chuckles] So, okay. So, uh, I wanna switch to talk about stable coins. Um, you are, uh, a longtime Bitcoiner. 16:08 I think a lot of people like think, "Oh, well, a Bitcoiner, you know, they don't, they don't pay attention to anything that happens outside of Bitcoin, and they, they hate other cryptocurrencies, and they hate all these things." 16:19 But I just think that's like an ostrich with their head under the sand. The world is dynamic, and a lot of these things have real value and are really changing, uh, the, the world around us. Stable coins, uh, may, uh... 16:35 So I wanna have a conversation with, with you about stable coins. Um, 16:39 you know, I think back ten years ago and the cypherpunks who kind of came up and codified a lot of the early Bitcoin language, I don't see them talking about like digital dollars. 16:51 I didn't see them talking about stable coins. What's your thought about this? 16:55 Like, why, you know, why did, why are stable coins like arguably one of the killer apps of our ecosystem that some of the progenitors of the Bitcoin world may not have predicted? 17:09 I mean, the, you know, the Bitcoin white paper is peer-to-peer electronic cash system, and I happen to have always, maybe it's me projecting, you've always got to project your views onto Bitcoin. Everyone does. 17:20 I've happened to believe that the cash there primarily means bearer asset, not so much literally day-to-day payment vehicle. However, in the white paper, Satoshi does say payments on the Internet. 17:30 He does appear to be talking about day-to-day payments. 17:33 And certainly there's been a rift in Bitcoin about whether it is primarily best thought of as a monetary and store value asset or as a medium of exchange and payments asset. 17:43 That's been a debate that has characterized Bitcoin's history for years, and it continues to, frankly. Um, just, you know, this week, Square is turning on Bitcoin payments at all of their terminals. 17:53 I think it's the biggest point-of-sale vendor in the United States. 17:56 It may, you know, you've got the Lightning Network, which obviously is focused around the medium of exchange use case, but then you've got the ETFs and the digital gold thesis, which have taken offI think there's clear product market fit for Bitcoin there, but not quite product market fit at scale for payments, right? 18:11 And, you know, in the face of that, um, there was sort of narrative room for someone to build something that competed with that idea. And, and then separately, you know, Bitcoin is very volatile historically, right? 18:23 Y-y-y-you-- Dollars are volatile very slowly to the downside only, right? 18:28 But slow enough that you don't quite notice, and you're able to spend them, and that's sort of where that two percent Fed inflation target comes from. They, they know they need inflation long term. 18:38 That's part of their, the strategy of fiat money. But it needs to be small enough that you don't quite notice, and so that you're willing to spend it, right? 18:45 'Cause, um, in co-in countries where they have, like, hyperinflation, it debases really quickly. People just dump it as soon as they can, right? And eventually end up weaving baskets out of it, like in Venezuela. 18:56 If the money appreciates, people don't spend as much. That's their fiat theory, and so they, they want something that's just slow enough. Bitcoin's been too volatile to the upside. 19:04 I mean, anyone that-- I mean, look at Laszlo hi-Hayek, Ha-Henyck? I always forget how to say his last name. Friedrich Hayek? Yeah. No, no. La-Laszlo, the Bitcoin pizza guy. Oh, Laszlo Hayek. Yeah. Also- The GPU guy. 19:15 The GPU pizza guy. Henyck? Henyck? Yeah. Yeah, I think he's probably fine 'cause he was mining a lot of Bitcoin at the time, but d-do we think he resent, r-you know, regrets this ten thousand BTC pizza pur-uh, purchase? 19:25 Probably. Probably. Right? So I think- He says he doesn't bother himself too much. He had it against hurt himself too much, you know? [chuckles] Well, he better not or he s-wouldn't sleep at night. Yeah. 19:34 [chuckles] I mean, he's gotta figure out how not to bother himself. It's a lot of money. 19:37 So, um, look, I think the emergence of a dollar asset that uses similar technology to Bitcoin is sort of inevitable, and before stables were widely adopted in crypto, people used to do this trade on BitMEX. 19:49 BitMEX was crypto only, no KYC, no stable coins. So to, to go flat, you would basically long the underlying and short the perp. That would be you going flat when you didn't wanna be in the market or vice versa. 20:02 Um, there's been a demand for a stable asset in the crypto markets forever. 20:06 Um, and in some ways, the debanking of Bitfinex and some of the crypto firms in, like, seventeen and eighteen is what really led to the rise of stable coins. So it's ironic as well. 20:17 But, um, I-- look, I think that the, the a digital dollar that is on a blockchain is a really good innovation for a lot of use cases. It's not immutable, okay? 20:28 Like, y-- they can freeze and seize, but they can do that today with bank dollars as well. Um, there is a, I would say, a self-sovereign upgrade here, which is that you can self-custody the digital dollar. 20:39 Like, it's not just holding a balance on your, you know, Venmo or Cash App. You can actually hold the dollar tokens and, and have only a liability to the issuer and not to a third-party platform or anything like that. 20:50 Um, and the re-- whether, you know, Bitcoiners like it or not, we live in a, in a dollar economy, and we still do, and I don't think Bitcoin is very close to depla-displacing that. 21:01 So stables are a meaningful upgrade for payments. 21:03 I think if you look at the, the financial and payments, uh, like, ecosystem or, like, technology stack, you'll find that it is a intertwining, like, absolute garbled mess of s-of systems just stacked on top of each other. 21:18 You practically need an archeological degree in order to untangle how payments, and, and by the way, stocks too, how they work. 21:25 Um, and stable coins are, are very disruptive for that, uh, to the benefit of the consumer and, and businesses that send and receive dollar payments. So there's even more I could say. 21:34 I think there's also a big geopolitical angle here as well, but- Yeah... it's, it's just an obvious upgrade. 21:39 Um, like Bitcoiners can, you know, there's a few, like the guy that took his family around the world and lives in a van. 21:44 Like, there are, there are notable people who've lived on a Bitcoin standard, but still that's very difficult today. 21:49 And, and most people, uh, even Bitcoin maxis, who might, you might think that they don't, they still use dollars, right? 21:55 And so why not have a better dollar upgrade in the interim, even if you believe that Bitcoin would displace the dollar for medium of exchange? [upbeat music] Hey, Will here with Blockspace Media. 22:07 Did you know that we have individual feeds for all our shows? If you're watching The Mining Pod, Bitcoin Season Two, or The Court Show, be sure to check out the individual feeds. 22:16 You can find them on your podcast player of choice, whether that be Spotify, Apple, YouTube, et cetera. Just type in Blockspace Media, and you'll find all our shows pop up. 22:25 Or just type in the individual show name, like The Mining Pod or Bitcoin Season Two. Be sure to hit that subscribe and give us a five-star rating so we can continue to bring you the best content in Bitcoin. 22:38 Uh, you, you brought up, like, some of the genesis of the stablecoin, uh, era ties back to Bitfinex, out of which came Tether, who is, like, the giant. 22:52 Um, but now we, you know, there's been a stablecoin explosion, obviously a lot of, uh, good, uh, a lot of productive, like, framework being made at the US government level and, uh, Genius and Clarity Acts coming out, um, maybe more stablecoin bills, we'll see. 23:11 Uh, but it's interesting because we've seen almost, like, now kind of a stablecoin pecking order emerge where we have USDT, uh, be the clear king and winner, but Circle also continue to have a good IPO. 23:27 What's your take on the stablecoin pecking order, U-USDT now to be the, the US, um, approved USAT? I don't know, like, what is, what does the future look like for all these different stablecoin plays going forwards? 23:45 Yeah. I mean, Tether, obviously the global juggernaut. Um, Circle, I would s- the biggest US-based issuer. 23:52 And you mentioned USAT, which is Tether's announced, I think a subsidiary, but will be their US offered version of USDT. 24:01 Um, the, the Genius Act requires either compliance with a US federal framework, which has basic stuff like collateral type, um, you know, uh, KYC on the create, redeem, bankruptcy remotenessUm, a variety of general good safety measures, I would argue that, um, and then it allows for a state pathway in the US. 24:22 So if you're below ten billion in issuance, you can issue through a state license rather than get the federal license. 24:27 But that's only if the treasury secretary says that the state license is substantially similar to the federal license. But, you know, it might be cheaper, for example, for a startup to go through a state. 24:39 Or you can be, uh, issuing in a foreign jurisdiction that the treasury secretary has determined, uh, is, has reciprocity with. 24:47 So, for example, you might see, right, there, there, there are pretty advanced frameworks in Europe, in Hong Kong, in parts of the Middle East that the treasury secretary could say, "These are substantially similar," and, you know, that's okay, then you don't need a US one, you can use that one. 25:02 I don't know, but I don't think El Salvador's will be determined for that. I mean, I can't know. It's possible. That's where Tether is headquartered, right? Yeah. 25:09 So theoretically, though, they could pass one in El Salvador. If the treasury secretary says, "You know what? That one meets our s- minimum standard," um, then maybe they don't need USAT. 25:20 And everyone's been wondering what Tether was gonna do here because definitively offshore, everyone knows that, right? Um, but you kind of have to be onshore. 25:28 I mean, the, the, the foreign reciprocity like that really remains to be seen. I mean, this is one of the questions Treasury is asking for comments on, like what-- how should the treasury secretary weigh the reciprocity? 25:39 And so we don't really know. But we do know that if you have a US license from the feds, you could do it, right? 25:45 So then we're like, okay, well, is Tether gonna come onshore, um, or might they stay offshore entirely and say, "We don't need the US," or might they launch the subsidiary? And it looks like it's the last one. 25:55 They are launching it. To-- Stepping back to your question, Charlie, like, what does in a more mature state that, that, uh- Yeah... list of the pecking order, as you said, look like. 26:06 I mean, you're gonna see banks and consortia of banks and financial companies issue stable coins, um, almost certainly. So the question is, um, you know, can one of them displace the Tethers and Circles? 26:21 Um, y- by the way way, you can be a stable value asset, we think, according to the Genius Act, although again, a lot of this has to be determined and rule made by the Treasury. 26:30 You can be a stable value asset that doesn't market yourself as a stable coin and can't be used for interbank payments without registering. So you could imagine there, there might be some, um, like take like Dai, right? 26:43 MakerDAO's- Yeah... stablecoin. It can't comply with Genius. Its collateral is not ninety-two-day Treasuries or less or repos. It has crypto as collateral. 26:51 As far as I-- unless plain read of the Genius Act makes that impos- it doesn't mean it's, it, it doesn't mean it will be illegal in the United States. It just means it can't say it's a stablecoin and banks can't use it. 27:02 But we envision a world where basically, anytime you send money anywhere, dollars, it is stablecoins, whether in the front or the back end, right? 27:09 Because it is just genuinely significantly better than sending a wire and watching it disappear for hours and not knowing if it's landed and the ACH. They're just not good. Um, so we think it'll be used by everybody. 27:22 And so the question is like, will that be banks? Will it be Circle? Will it be Tether? Well, no, no one quite knows. I, I, I would not count out the banks', um, you know, anger here and, and r- 27:34 r- we're one of the only countries in the world that where banks are big, big players in the payments system. Um, I don't think that's right. I think banks are [sighs] antiquated in many ways, right? 27:46 Like, I think they're gonna try to play here, but, um, I think you're gonna see a lot of upstart stuff, I think. 27:51 But one of the other interesting things to look at is these stablecoin issuers' primary business model is collecting the interest on the collateral, right? 27:58 And, um, there are debates about whether or not the Genius Act allows them to pass any of that yield back to their token holders. 28:05 Most think that it, they can't give them directly to token holders, but theoretically, like you could, you know, an issuer could give some marketing spend to an intermediary, and then they could reward. 28:15 It is-- But think about this, in a falling rates environment, that revenue's gonna dry up. 28:20 So you're starting to see stablecoin issuers launch their own blockchains because they wanna monetize at the transaction level the same way that the payments companies like Visa and Mastercard do. Yeah. 28:30 So you've got Arc from Circle. Right. You've got Tempo. You've got Tempo. Yeah. You've got Plasma, which is, you know, like Tether affiliated or something. 28:38 Um, so that might also be an interesting thing to watch in terms of the pecking order. Like, how do these things monetize? 28:44 Um, u- unless you're at scale, it's not a particularly good business, stablecoins, as far as I can tell, at least in the current iteration. So we'll see some business model evolution as well. 28:53 Yeah, it seems like there's g- this is like the place to watch. Like, w- as this market emerges and matures, there will be the pecking order. We'll have to watch. 29:03 Uh, we, we, maybe we can make like a little like ranking chart, be like, "Here's the, here's the unofficial pecking order if you're in the US." 29:10 So- And, and you don't want like, if they're fungible, and they should be fungible, even though there's- Yeah... this setup is not... 29:15 In a CBDC construct, it would be one issuer, your central bank, and so of course it would be fungible. 29:20 One of the criticisms, um, of people that are pro CBDC but anti-private stablecoins is like, "Well, we're gonna have fifty stable coins. Like, why?" It's like free banking, you know, wildcat banking era. 29:30 But the reality is this sets a very high bar in federal standards. So like there's really no reason why, like you wouldn't accept Circle, Tether versus USDC if they were both regulated under this framework. 29:42 Nonetheless, like why would a bank, if I-- if its customers are depositing stable coins at it, at it, surely they'd want it to be their own stable, right? Because then at least they also collect the underlying interest. 29:54 So, uh, it's, it's not clear, frankly, and, and I've worked a lot on this, and the fact that I don't have a strong view is actually kind of frightening to me. 30:01 It's not clear if we're gonna have two or three winners or like fifty or a hundred competitors that, that play. It's not quite clear yet. So the banks- It feels-... are throwing up a big stink on this, I can tell you. 30:11 It feels like, you know, what's funny is, is this feels a lot like the L one, like the blockchain L one trade from like the late twenty tens.Where it's like, are we gonna have one smart contract blockchain or is, are we gonna have all these disruptions? 30:24 Uh, it s- seems we're, like entering that era for stable coins where it's- Yeah... kind of up in the air. We'll see. Um, couple more questions about stable coins. Uh, they gotta be backed by something. 30:36 You know, US Treasuries are a popular one, but, like, there's Bitcoin-backed stable coins. Tether's diversifying into, like, you know, business venture, and, like, what do you see the future of that? 30:47 It-- and I guess, like, is a Bitcoin-backed stable coin ever competitive? Is this at all, like, a feasible idea at scale? It's volatile. I don't know. What are your thoughts? Um, I like it. I think it can work. 31:00 It wouldn't be legal to be a stable coin. A- actually, what I should say is it wouldn't be a legal permitted payment stablecoin in the United States. Ugh. That is the legal language, uh, in the Genius Act. 31:10 Those have to be backed by cash-like instruments and short-term US debt. Um, but that, like I said before, it doesn't mean it would be illegal, right? And, and, and, uh, y-you could offer... 31:21 I think we're pretty sure, although again, this is up in the air still from the lack of Treasury rulemaking yet, but they're asking about this. 31:28 I'm of the view that y-you know, digital asset service providers, I'm using another legal term from the bill- [laughs]... 31:34 should be allowed to offer the, for conversion or sale these types of other stable assets, whether it's a Bitcoin-backed stable, whether it's something like Ethena, which uses the Basis trade, like, that should be allowed. 31:45 It just can't be a stable coin, right? Like, why-- So, um, I, I like it. I, I also frankly still like, you know, collateralized debt position stables like Dai as a design area as well. 31:59 So I, I think all of this is mostly on the table. 32:01 The only one type that is likely to be outright illegal are, uh, algorithmic stable coins that are backed by an endoges- that are collateralized by an endogenous asset, endogenous collateral, meaning like a- The Terra, Terra Luna concept. 32:15 Yeah, Terra as the coin with Luna. But or, like, if there was an F-- if FTX had released one and backed it with FTT, right? Like- Yeah... where the issuer is backing it with its own. 32:25 Now, that's not even actually banned in the Genius Act, but they're, you know, required to do a study about it. 32:29 Um, we obviously think those are inherently dangerous, but, um, there are many other forms that can work, right? It's just a matter of, you know, good management, proper disclosure. 32:39 That's one thing the Genius Act requires. Like, you will get fined if you market something that doesn't meet those requirements as a stablecoin to, um, you know, US users. 32:47 So I think there's pretty, pretty strict controls around, like, the r- the downside risk of other non, uh, Treasury and cash-backed stable coins. 32:57 But, um, I'm, I'm very open to, you know, the experimentation in crypto for these types of things. 33:03 I, I, you know, stable coins, just to drive the point home, they do not solve the problem with the US dollar, which is that it's down ninety-nine percent over its life. 33:12 And will-- And, and like, you know, any coin that you might, you might hold forever, like, when you think being down ninety-nine percent is as far as it can go, like, I'm sorry to tell you, it can always go down another ninety-nine percent. 33:25 Um, and so it, it, it solves a payment thing and a dollar distribution problem. It extends the reach of the US dollar. 33:32 For all I know, you at the Genius Act will have expan- extended the dominance of the dollar as the global reserve currency by thirty more years or something, some number, right? 33:41 Like, it's a very important geopolitical thing that has real-world positive impact for individuals and businesses. It doesn't solve or impact at all the Federal Reserve's debasement of the US dollar. 33:52 That was literally my, uh, my, like, kinda leve- uh, capstone question was, like, stable coins, do they reinforce the system? Are we actually disrupting the system? Did we get co-opted? 34:05 You know, this is stepping back as, like, the revolutionary- Yeah... putting on my, my cyberpunk anarchist hat a bit here. Like, 34:13 did we lose the-- Are we losing the plot, or do we just have to adapt to a new, uh, just the reality of the, the market forces? I mean, you, you're... 34:23 The, the launch of stable coins absolutely lowers the likelihood or pushes farther out the adoption of, say, Bitcoin as a widespread medium of, uh, of exchange. It absolutely does. 34:35 Um, and but, you know, as far as the bull case for BTC, like, I really don't think a lot of people have been buying BTC under the premise that it would be used as a medium of exchange. 34:44 So I don't think it materially dents the, the bull case for BTC, uh, in any sort of meaningful way. 34:53 Like, I don't think most of the buyers that brought us from twenty K to a hundred K did so because they thought it would be used to buy coffee. I don't believe that. So I, you know... 35:02 A-and look, broadly, it's not just with stables, but, you know, talking about Bitcoin being owned by, uh, pensions and endowments and in ETF vehicles, like, has that lost the plot? 35:11 I mean, I am a big supporter of owning Bitcoin in self-custody cold storage. But, you know, this is kinda what winning looks like. 35:19 I don't know, people, did they think that, you know, uh, uh, pensions are gonna, like, have Trezors and cold cards in a safe? Like- Yeah... that's simply not how they operate. 35:29 In some cases, they're prohibited by law from operating like that. They need to use qualified custody. It's just simply not a realistic expectation. 35:38 Um, I, you know, I think we can do things to reinforce some of the cyberpunk values that are really positive, like self-sovereignty or privacy or permissionless payments and immutability by sort of, you know, Trojan horsing this thing in the front door, right? 35:54 And that's kind of what's gonna happen, I think. 35:57 Um, you're not gonna get all of the features that the most pure Bitcoin maximalist wanted, adopted by governments or, like, mainstreamed in the population, but you're gonna get some. 36:08 And I think in general, not just for Bitcoin or stables or another one I look a lot at is tokenized stocks, which is probably a topic for another day, but, like, where the, th-there is a clear push and pull between decentralization and centralization. 36:21 The line exists somewhere in twenty-fifteen or twenty-- two thousand eight, two thousand nine.It's going to be meaningfully further on the decentralization side for all of these. Uh, the question is where, right? 36:34 Where on that spectrum will it sort of find an equilibrium and a stasis? And that question is live for Bitcoin, it's live for stable coins, it's live for other things. 36:43 And I think, you know, the Bitcoin industry and, and the crypto industry has meaningfully pulled it towards decentralization. You're getting pushback. 36:51 Bank Policy Institute continues to write angry letters about tokenized stocks, about stable coins, right? That represents the world's biggest banks. 36:58 Um, they're gonna, they're gonna resist, and they have been resisting, but they, you know, they're also... 37:03 It's not even just about centralization versus decentralization, it's about incumbent versus challenger and innovation, the innovator's dilemma, that they would always resist. 37:10 It wouldn't matter if it was controversial or just merely innovative. 37:14 Um, and I think we've done a really good job introducing very disruptive technology into money, into payments, into equities, into all of these areas where block- public blockchains are making an impact. 37:26 And I think it's gonna end, I don't know if it'll ever end, but it, we're, we're-- it will find an equilibrium in a far, far closer to the decentralization side of that spectrum than ever before over, you know, over time. 37:38 Yeah. We're definitely still pissing off some of the right people, so that's always a good sign. 37:43 [laughs] Uh, so I guess wrapping this up, um, you know, the Bitcoin Season two narrative that, uh, this podcast gets its genesis from Bitcoin Season two, this like this ebullience, this optimism a-among new types of assets, new things happening on Bitcoin, ordinals, runes. 38:02 There was a layer two explosion a year and a half ago. A lot of that momentum is down. The Bitcoin Season two narrative feels very stale right now. Um, what are your thoughts about this? 38:15 You know, was that just a, was that a one-off event, or do we just kinda wait for things to pick back up again? Where's your head at on this? Uh, I think it had... The momentum for Bitcoin Season two has stalled. 38:26 I think there's no doubt about that. Obviously, if you look at ordinals and runes and these layer one, uh, assets, the-they're way-- they're down hugely in terms of both narrative attention, adoption, prices, right? 38:37 Um, the layer two stuff I, I, I don't think has fully materialized yet, but it's very interesting. You know, I'm, I'm waiting for, you know, things like Botanix and Citria and Alpen to, to launch meaning- fully. 38:51 I think maybe Botanix has launched partially. Botanix is live, but, you know, it's, it's slow. It's, it's- It's early... early. I think they launched this summer. I'm, I'm a- Yeah... disclosure. 38:58 I'm an investor, but yeah, so yeah. Yes, and, and I-- and disclosure, Galaxy is a Citria investor as well. Yeah. 39:04 So, but, you know, I, I, I don't think that's fully played out yet, but one interesting thing, I mean, which is not the topic for this show, but they've become embroiled in this arbitrary data and filters debate that is new. 39:16 It's always been around, but like- So we... Yeah... I mean, it's as old as time- Yeah... but this one's particularly heated. I mean, Citria in particular has found itself- [laughs] Yeah... 39:25 embroiled because they had a white paper where they said perhaps they would use those fake outputs- Yeah... the way like Stamps does. 39:32 Um, e-even though I don't think they do or plan to, they did say they looked at it, and then what Antoine Poisset and other Bitcoin developers pointed that to that as one example of the risk of not expanding the op return, uh, da-data carrier size, 39:48 um, field. So, um, now they're sort of directly embroiled. It's not clear whether the filterers are mad about illegal content or merely degenerate content, or if they're mad about ZKPs. I mean- Yeah... 40:00 from my perspective, layer twos posting proofs on the blockchain to enable other monetary off-chain transactions is effectively the scaling, uh, roadmap that's been described and adopted by Bitcoin for over a decade. 40:15 So I... But, you know, they're, they're concerned because, you know, Citria or Botanix or Alpen might also have like what? Monkey JPEGs on them effectively. No, I think- You know, I think that's where it comes from. 40:23 So it, it's this really interesting push and pull because the ordinals brought this like Bitcoin Season two really to the forefront, but it also will end up being a headwind where, you know, whereas if, 40:35 i-i-if, you know... So I, I don't know where that lands. I don't think the story is really fully played out on the L2s yet because they really haven't meaningfully launched. Shout out to Willem and the team at Botanix. 40:44 They did launch, but, um, it's early, early, early, right? So I don't, I don't know. And, and honestly, I mean, if you had like BIP four four four or whatever, it's not the real BIP name obviously- Yeah... 40:53 but if you had this new proposal enacted, they'd be kind of bricked potentially. I mean, of course, they'd find a way to post, and that's sort of the ironic problem with the filtering. But in any case, like it... 41:04 So e-even at that, uh, consensus level, I, I highly doubt it, but if we were to see like meaningful restrictions put in place on arbitrary data, then that would also impact the story for L2s, and that hasn't fully played out yet either. 41:16 So still early. Um, I, I still think it's very interesting when people use Bitcoin in strange new ways. So, um, I, I still like to see that, you know. 41:25 And, and look, it's not impeding at all in the monetary use of Bitcoin. Let's be real. Fees are like nothing. So, like, let's... 41:30 It-- that's the other irony, is that there's even a debate about, like, whether or not these L2s would be legitimate, a, a legitimate use of block space when block space is basically free today. Cheaper than- Yeah... 41:42 it's been in a long time. Yeah. I think the reason, like, you and I are so, we look at it so closely is 'cause we like to analyze, we like to look at the stuff. 41:50 If you're in the research business, you're trying to pump your research bags, the more interesting stuff that happens on-chain- It is actually true... the more interesting stuff you guys can do. 41:58 I mean, if this is just a send, receive, hold network only, n- let's say no covenants, no timestamps, not even multisig, uh, that's pretty boring from a data and research standpoint. And I mean, I, I... 42:10 You know, we put out a, a case where we thought that the ordinal market could become really big, and now we put that out. It did almost get to our target, by the way, before it pulled back. 42:19 But, um, more than anything, I just think it's interesting what people are using it for. And, and I think there's more interesting stuff ahead. Uh, the top is not in on Bitcoin being used for interesting stuff. 42:31 The top is not in for Bitcoin being used on interesting stuff. 42:35 Um, I completed my infinity gauntlet almost of the Galaxy Research Squad with Alex, but as, uh, you guys put out more research, I will tap you to come on and talk about it. 42:46 One of my favorite ops out there in the Bitcoin space. Alex, thank you so much for coming on the pod, and I will see you in person at a conference again someday soon. Absolutely. Thank you so much, Charlie. 43:01 [outro music]