Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome back to Bitcoin Season 2. 0:35 This is the Metrics-- Ecosystem Metrics and News Update. I'm Charlie Spears of Blockspace Media. Bitcoin Season 2 is produced by Blockspace Media. 0:44 Check out our other, uh, products, our content, "The GORC Show," "Mining Pod," "Writer's Room" on Fridays, Bitcoin Season 2 VOD on Thursdays, "The Mining Pod" and our newsletter, blockspace.media. 0:56 Before we get kicked off, um, uh, I'm proud to say that Bitcoin Season 2 is brought to you by Botanix Labs. 1:03 Botanix Labs is pioneering a new direction for DeFi with the first EVM layer-two running on Bitcoin that's built to be forward secure, decentralized, and share gas fees generated by the network with users to see the future of DeFi from Botanix Labs, botanixlabs.xyz. 1:21 So again, thank you for joining. This is the Ecosystem Metrics and News Update, where I basically scour the internet so that you don't have to. 1:30 If you took a break from the internet, first of all, good on you, um, for, for getting off the screen. It's been a long and hard bear market. But I basically stare into the abyss. 1:41 I look at this black mirror so that you don't have to. And so I'm going to see what happened in the world of ordinals and broader Bitcoin Season 2 stuff. So without further ado, um, we are back, baby. 1:58 You made it through a bear market. I'm pulling up the Magic Eden, um, past thirty-day look here, and you can see it across the board, with the exception of two collections, the top ten collections, everything is up. 2:10 And several things are up on the month massively. 2:14 The thirty-day net gain percentage, NodeMonks forty-one percent, Puppets seventy-one percent, Rune Stones up ten percent, OMB seven, Quantum Cats eight, Frogs fifty-seven percent. That's like the OG ordinals collection. 2:29 You do love to see it. Um, and you just keep going down. Like, just look at the top fifty. Yeah, there's some red on here, but your JPEGs, they are up on the month. Um, you know, don't squander this opportunity. 2:43 Use it wisely. And of course, this is not financial advice. I personally recommend that you DCA. Let's take a look at the metrics. I'm gonna pull up my personal favorite, um, 2:58 uh, dashboard, which is data always dashboard, Dune dashboard. In fact, I'm surprised that more people don't look at this. 3:04 I will say that I, I pulled this up and nobody had rerun the charts in, [chuckles] I think twelve days. There are-- I find that I actually think I'm usually the only person actually running the metrics on these charts. 3:16 So anyway, we crossed over seventy million total inscriptions. This is slowing down a bit. Like, if we go down and we look, like, inscriptions really did just drop off a cliff after the halving. 3:27 I'll pull back and I'll say, like, hey, um, consider that, like, I remember back in the day, Casey, the creator of Ordinals himself, thought, well, it might, um, we might never even, you know, might-- it would be considered a success if we got, like, ten thousand inscriptions total. 3:43 Well, even then, we are still getting, um, twenty to thirty thousand inscriptions per day. This is not nearly the-- what we saw, the heights of, uh, inscription volume, 3:56 um, that is in the four hundred to five hundred thousand, um, inscription amount per day. But, like, look at this. 4:04 I mean, if we are just doing, uh, several tens of thousands of inscriptions per day, this is still pretty significant in my view. Maybe this represents, like, a long-term base in demand. 4:17 Like, you might almost call this a base load of Bitcoin block space base load. More on that topic, actually. Let's just go right to mempool.space. 4:27 Um, if you pay attention to fees like I do, and I'll be talking a little bit about this, uh, further today, um, you can see that we are currently at six to nine sats per vByte. 4:37 This, this does represent, like, a little bit of a spike right now in, um, transaction volume. But if we just look at the, um, overall chart for the past year, we've seen several spikes. 4:48 The initial inscription run in February '23, March '23, the BRC-20 boom of spring '23, and the, I call it the, um, the meta-protocol explosion of winter '23 and early '24. 5:04 Since then, we've seen the, the mempool pretty much clear off, except for the runes launch at the halving. But we still have a significant amount of, like, backlog of transactions. 5:15 But anyway, the spot, like, the spot-like place where we are right now for, uh, for fees is six to nine sats per vByte. 5:26 Just for context, two years ago, um, summer of 2022, we were at-- sitting at one to maybe two sats per vByte. 5:34 So just pulling really far back on the two-- Over the past couple years, we have increased eight to nine X in, like, base level fees. So again, that's oversimplifying, but I do think this is pretty significant. 5:49 Um, the other, um... I will just linger here a bit more on some charts. I'll look down at this chart. My favorite-- It's one of my favorite charts. It's the monthly inscription share chart. 6:03 This shows you of all the inscriptions that are happening, all the ordinals that are being put on-chain.What percentage of them are BRC-20? Which, which of them are JSON, like the text? 6:15 Um, which of them are images, like the NFTs that you might buy on Magic Eden? 6:21 Well, this pink, uh, section here is the images, and we can see that in the past week, images, your, like conventional profile picture, NFTs or art, accounted for close to half. 6:33 That is forty-five percent of all inscription-- new inscriptions on chain. That's pretty significant in my view because like, yes, you can speculate on your BRC-20 tokens. That's super fun. 6:43 I hope your bags go up, whatever. But this kinda gets to the core and the, the heartbeat of what Ordinals really are, which is this thesis of art and, um, putting data on chain. 6:55 So this is a pretty interesting phenomenon to watch. Um, as I have identified in previous live streams, um, [clicks tongue] typically when fees go down on chain, the share of inscriptions, the share of images increases. 7:12 So we saw this happen this past summer where in the month of August and September, as fees plummeted to basically like zero on Bitcoin, uh, we saw the rate-- the percentage of images and JPEGs increase. 7:26 So we continue, we continue to see this thesis of mine validated, um, and I think this may be accelerated a bit as the token speculation moved a lot to Fractal over the past month. 7:38 On the subject of Fractal, um, while this is not like super directly related to Bitcoin, it does relate to the broader Bitcoin ecosystem and economy, and it has pretty deep implications for Bitcoin's mining dynamics. 7:52 So I will pay attention to Fractal here. Fractal peaked, um, a couple weeks ago at about thirty dollars, some odd dollars per Fractal Bitcoin. It's a separate token on a separate blockchain, to be clear, 8:08 and it's been declining. It currently sits, Fractal Bitcoin sits about seven point five US dollars, um, and activity on Fractal has dropped off a cliff. Just to like, 8:22 you know, give you a snapshot here, if I'm looking at the Unisat Explorer, each block right now is like only adding about one to, to three like Fractal Bitcoin per block in fees. 8:34 At its peak, like mid-September, this was sitting at like fifty Fractal Bitcoin per block, while Fractal Bitcoin was at like twenty or thirty dollars. 8:42 So we see like fee activity driving Fractal revenue significantly down. 8:49 I would recommend if you wanna hear more about this, go listen to, um, previous interviews I've done with Lorenzo or, uh, the Bitcoin Season 2 Writers' Room with Colin from a few weeks ago, or read the blockspace.media, uh, newsletters that I and other Blockspace contributors have written. 9:08 So moving on from Fractal back to a Dune dashboard. I'm only gonna show you one, and that is the volume by marketplace. This is Domo's dashboard. Domo of BRC-20 fame. You may not know this. 9:21 Before he did BRC-20, he was actually like a Dune dashboard guy. Domo's like origination is in the like metrics and analytics game. 9:31 So here's Domo, and he made a Dune dashboard for Ordinals, and you can see that the volume by marketplace, this is what the, the chart we're looking at. The volume by marketplace right now, um, kinda sucks. 9:43 Like it's just down and to the right. We are doing maybe, um, if I'm looking at this right, like two million dollars per day in total marketplace volume. This is, and I use the term anemic. 10:02 It's like starving. Now why did I title the name of this stream, "You Made It Through to Ordinals Bear Market"? 10:08 Well, I think it's because, um, while the volume might be low, like the collection prices are up, and I'm going to tease this for you a bit tomorrow on the Blockspace newsletter. 10:19 I'm going to-- I've just finished up writing a piece on the, like diving into Liquidium data with partnership from like Liquidium data, Liquidium data guy just to like say, "Hey, look, it looks like you, uh, Ordinals users are getting more sophisticated, but liquidations are decreasing over time." 10:38 So make sure you sign up for our newsletter, blockspace.media. Um, so yeah, the Ordinals market does seem to be recovering. Let's get into the news. I'm done with charts. No more charts, don't worry. 10:51 Um, [chuckles] I see Joshua Holt says, "Can we please talk about Magic Internet Money?" I might talk about it next week. I think that's a pretty interesting one. 10:58 I spent a, a couple weeks in Asia, Joshua, and it's pretty clear to me that the Magic Internet Money people, uh, really i-in Asia are a very, very strong community. So I will-- I have that on my radar. 11:12 Thanks for bringing that up. Um, in the news, I have the Alchemia trading competition. 11:20 Now, this might not be on any of your radar, but I think this should be because a lot of us tr- um, a lot of the focus is like, well, I want to inscribe something on Bitcoin, but the fee rates are high. 11:33 Or like, oh, there's a big mint happening. Oh, the, you know, this affects Bitcoin fee rates. Well, how do I, how do I capture? How do I speculate on fee rates? 11:42 Alchemia, who I did an interview with, again, a previous Bitcoin Season 2 episode, Alchemia has an interesting way to bet on Bitcoin L1 fee rates, and they have a trading competition right now. It runs for about a week. 11:56 And um, I think this is, this is going to be increasingly important in the news cycle going forward because when there are spikes in fee rates, when someone's doing a big mint or there's some big event like the Babylon chain staking event coming up next week-This can generate fees, and this is a great way to capture ordinals alpha. 12:18 That is right. Yes, I'm giving you some free alpha here, which is [chuckles] go, uh, hedge your fee rates. 12:25 Like, if you know there's a big mint coming up and you think fee rates are underpriced, go to Alchemia, check it out. I think it's a very fascinating website. Um, we're not sponsored by them. I just think it's... 12:34 I personally use it to hedge my own fee rates and to take short week to two-week long positions on fee rates. So, um, they have a trading competition going on right now. 12:44 They've done a hundred Bitcoin in, um, volume so far, and I think the next period opens up October 8th through 9th. Next in the news. One of my favorite accounts and, um, [chuckles] 12:59 uh, one of my favorite accounts is the Monk Appraiser. Uh, I recommend you follow this. This is someone who does, like, NodeMonk, like, trait evaluation, but they also do a lot of interesting data. 13:14 And this is an interesting data, uh, visualization basically throwing out a bull thesis for, um, art on Bitcoin. 13:26 And this basic- This says we're gonna compare other existing markets like the total addressable market of the, uh, secular art market, that is normal art in the real world. Let's-- What if, like... 13:37 What if, you know, uh, ordinals represented a similar share of the market on Bitcoin to the global art-art market? Well, this is an interesting chart. 13:47 Similarly, um, ordinals market cap compared to Bitcoin's market cap, let's look at what that would be normalized if it were NFTs on Eth. 13:56 So all of these, these three different part-- pie charts tell the story that, um, if ordinals is to mirror other art markets, either on-chain or in the real world, then we still have several multiples to go to the upside. 14:11 Yeah, it seems like I'm, I'm feeding you too much bull hopium, but isn't that, like, kind of the job of us talking heads? Like, nobody wants to see us making doomer predictions. That's a very short-lived meta. 14:23 I think, as an optimist, I think, uh, Bitcoin's gonna go up, and these beta assets, if you will, these ordinals-related assets, might function as betas to Bitcoin. Monk Appraiser certainly thinks so. 14:37 Here's a very interesting chart. I recommend you go check this out. So in other news, moving on. Um, everybody is talking about who Satoshi is. There's this HBO documentary coming out. 14:49 If you hadn't heard about this, then you probably weren't online in the past week. But supposedly, HBO is coming out with a documentary which says, "We know who Satoshi is." And I'll just... 14:59 I'll cut right to the pun-punchline. You don't have to watch it. 15:01 They're going to give you some bullshit answer about who Satoshi is, um, and they're gonna try to point to a specific person, and that person is not going to be correct. 15:11 Uh, but I think this is a good opportunity to look at what we do know about Satoshi, which is not, um, in Satoshi's writings. And I think one of the best examples of this is in what's-what we call the Patoshi pattern. 15:26 This account, Wicked, w_s_bitcoin, is one of the best accounts to follow if you are from the ordinals camp and looking to follow other good Bitcoin accounts. 15:36 Um, a lot of people wonder, how did we ever, um, figure out how Satoshi owns a million Bitcoin? Like, the-- all the Bitcoin that Satoshi owns. Well, 15:47 we actually figured out by looking at the blocks that Satoshi mined early on and, um, identifying a pattern. We call this pattern, as I show here, the Patoshi pattern. 16:01 And if you look at this really cool visualization, we can see, um, this pattern forming, and this is not something I'm going to explain. 16:10 We can basically identi-i-identify a fingerprint using, um, what's called nonce analysis and probabilities to say, "Okay, these blocks were probably mined by Satoshi." 16:22 And so we can then identify that Bitcoin and where that Bitcoin is in a wallet and say, "Okay, that Bitcoin is probably Satoshi's." That is how we figured out that Satoshi owns about a million Bitcoin. 16:34 So I highly recommend you check this out. 16:36 There's a lot of, like, discussion on Satoshi this week, and there was some then unrelated but kind of synchronicity-- synchronistic, um, discussion on the Patoshi pattern that I'm showing you here now. 16:49 So I recommend you check this out. Um, Sergio Lerner, uh, identified this pattern, and then other people have improved and verified this type of research, particularly Jameson Lopp. 17:00 And then Wicked, this-- you might know him as the Apple profile picture guy. He has kind of put it together in a very, like, digestible way. So, [lip smacks] 17:10 um, the last ordinals-related topic is, um, we got another Ord update. We got Ord o.20.1. That's Ord o.20.1. It's not a very big update, as Raph says here. 17:27 If you don't know Raph, he's the lead maintainer of the Ord GitHub. Ord is the reference client that Casey and Raph build, which says, "We're gonna implement ordinals." 17:36 And so basically anything new that happens in ordinals, um, starts here. 17:41 And so this is-- Yeah, you probably have to be a little more technically inclined, but I recommend, even if you're a degen, follow this stuff, follow Raph, follow Casey, follow the GitHub. 17:51 Whenever they put out updates, I'll cover them. So C- uh, Raph says, um, there's a new release for Ord o.20.1. Minor release but comes with some noteworthy improvements. Namely, 18:04 we've added multi-parent support to the wallet. You can now build complex family trees even more complex than nature allows. That's a joke. 18:14 That's a-- maybe a German joke because Raph's German.And, um, that basically means, like, you know how you can have the parent-child mechanism in Ordinals, where you have an input be an inscription and then one of the outputs be an inscription, so, like, your child inscription is associated with a parent inscription? 18:34 Well, now you can have multiple parents which is recognized in the client. This is already recognized on ordinals.com on the Explore side, but now it is officially recognized in the client. 18:44 That is the thing in command line that you might use or that RAF and a lot of the Ordinals devs use. So this is really interesting. I personally am very excited for this. 18:54 I have been concepting a collection like th- that uses multi-parent for a long time. Um, you can also, uh, burn... You can do a wallet burn command. That's added if you [chuckles] want to get really spicy. 19:08 Um, they improved the handbook. If you haven't checked out the Ordinals handbook in a while, I'd recommend that. Here's a link, docs.ordinals.com. And then, um, the indexing of runes specifically has been improved. 19:21 If you're not familiar with, like, what indexing is, it's basically when you look at all the Bitcoin blocks and you say which of these-- which of these relevant data to Ordinals or runes, we're going to go through all that and figure out which ones they are and index all those. 19:34 So that process has been pretty computationally expensive, and the latest client improves on that. There are a bunch of other small releases and updates, so you'll have to s- check the official, 19:47 um, uh, GitHub for the full release notes. On another note, if you're still here and you're still watching this, I'm going to give you some more alpha. 20:01 So if you haven't been paying attention, Blockspace Media, we are la-- we are, uh, launching our inaugural small technical conference in Boston, Massachusetts, next month on November ninth. 20:14 It is called Op Next, OP underscore Next. It is a, it is a scaling conference for Bitcoin builders, developers, and founders, and we have a stacked lineup. 20:26 That's as much as I can even really say because we have basically a who's who of the Bitcoin technical community. 20:33 A lot of people who've not even been in the same room together in a long time talking about how to fork Bitcoin. Um, both how to fork and then what to fork Bitcoin. 20:44 If you are one of the Op Cat people, if you're one of the, um, Quantum Cat people, this is a very interesting conference for you, and I'm going to give you live here on air a discount code. So, um, I recommend you go to 21:01 opnext.dev. Again, it's November ninth, next month in Boston, Massachusetts. We have John Attack, Armen Simoryan, Peter Todd, Pete Rizzo, Dan Gould, Riordan, Weiking Chen, Ethan Heiland, Ryan Delo the Wizard. 21:17 We have Jeremy Rubin. We have Tadge Dryja, the guy who invented Lightning. We have many, many more speakers at this conference. They're not even all posted yet because we've been adding a bunch of people really quickly. 21:30 So if you're still listening, um, you can use the discount code, one word, all caps, CHARLIE. That's my name, C-H-A-R-L-I-E. Use the discount code CHARLIE to get thirty percent off these tickets. 21:43 Yes, I'm shilling you tickets to my conference, but also, like, if you are interested in, um, Bitcoin technical discussion, you should come to this conference. 21:53 Um, if you have, like, a Bitcoin, uh, Ordinals dev or a Bitcoin dev that you think should be here, let us know. Send them here. 21:59 If you're one of those, like, like I said, teams who's building in Ordinals or you have, like, a technical person, this is the conference to send them to. 22:06 Um, this is where all the best Bitcoin developers and Bitcoin technical minds will be, as well as many Bitcoin mining representatives and stakeholders. So check it out. 22:16 Make sure to, um, uh, subscribe to all Bic- Blockspace Media stuff. blockspace.media is the website, Core Show, Mining Pod, Bitcoin Season Two, and I will see you all next week. 22:32 [outro music]