Transcript 0:00 At first blush, you might be like, "Well, yeah, of course. Just, you know, check the boxes. You obviously are-" But if you are, you could trade, bro. You can walk the trade. That's not how it works. 0:11 Now, this is very much a he said, she said story. Riddled with drama. 0:27 Welcome back to Block Space Live, presented by CleanSpark, y'all. Beautiful Friday, and the timeline is on fire with data center discourse, Charlie. We've really reached a fever pitch. It's r- knob cranked up to 11. 0:45 Everyone's weighing in on this, and there's almost nothing new to be said about it, but there are some interesting takes that we're gonna go over, along with a recent report from Axios that a coalition of Republicans are going to AI companies and saying, "Hey, y'all, you gotta get this messaging right, because we might lose Ohio," a key battleground state for the 2028 midterms. 1:09 That will cap off our show. We're gonna spend, uh, quite a bit of time on that. But before we get to that story, first we're going to be doing our usual hash rate index update. 1:19 Bitcoin mining metrics looking pretty juicy, because Bitcoin's [chuckles] chart is a hockey stick, literal hockey stick. 1:25 It's been a long time since I've seen a price movement like this, so we're gonna be looking at how it's impacting Bitcoin mining metrics. 1:32 Following that, we will be breaking down Keel's latest press release, where they come out in support of Governor Josh Shapiro's recent data center executive order, and talk about how it will not affect their Sharon and Panther Creek sites. 1:45 Following that, for our sole interview today, we have Craig Taveras, the president of Hive's Buzz HPC line. Uh, [laughs] just, just in, Colin. Uh, Craig has to reschedule, so we'll call an audible on this. All right. 2:02 Uh, don't you worry. Don't you worry. You keep going. We'll, we'll- All righty. Well-... wait till Craig goes live. That's unfortunate. We were gonna have Craig. 2:09 [laughs] We were gonna grill him on the Q2 and the HPC revamp, but that'll be forthcoming next week. So instead of that, we're just gonna turn this into the data center cry corner. No, no, no. 2:20 So- We're, we're gonna sub- we're gonna sub in, uh, a nice little story of, of everyone's favorite, uh, uh, trader, Ken Griffin, and s- and Citadel, and situational awareness, which I will cover. Okay. Yeah. 2:33 But what, what- All right... but basically, like, look, what Colin is trying to say is the only thing anybody wants to talk about today is data centers and how much everybody hates them. 2:42 And let it be known, you heard it here first on Block Space. They're saying the stuff we've been talking about for months. 2:50 I am an embedded operative in the Facebook groups, and I will be revealing, uh, and I have been revealing in previous episodes everything that I've been seeing. 2:59 And so now everybody's like, "Oh, we gotta care about data centers." Okay, so enough about that. We're gonna, uh... Let's finish up [laughs] this intro. Then we'll kick off with some hash rate index. 3:09 Block Space goes live every weekday at 1:00 PM Eastern, featuring quick hits on the latest in, what else? Data centers, because we are compute's daily live show. 3:20 If you like this live stream but miss it, you can catch it in podcast form anywhere podcasts are found. 3:26 If that's not enough, go to our website for the expanded Block Space suite of content, including a lot of written articles and newsletter. You can find our website at blockspace.media. 3:38 This show is brought to you by CleanSpark, NASDAQ-listed ticker CLSK. More on CleanSpark later. Before we talk about Keel and Pennsylvania, Colin, we have to talk about hash rate. 3:55 Look at this. The market's back, Colin. I mean, look at this beautiful candle here. Yeah. And if you look at the, the Bitcoin price chart, it's... I mean, it mirrors hash price, obviously- Yeah... right? 4:08 But it, it's, it's just an insane, uh, it- it's an insane vertical. It's just straight up. Th- there's like, there haven't been really any reprieves. Yeah. 4:18 And we're, we, we barely, uh, we almost bumped up against 80,000, a, a, a f- a number we haven't seen since May of this year. And as a result, per what you're showing here, Charlie, Bitcoin miners are loving it. 4:31 Hash price is back near a plump $38.69 per peta hash per day. Not quite $40 yet, but daggum, man, a damn good sight better than being in $30 or below $30 like it has been for most of the summer. Yeah. 4:49 We saw actually pico lows in June and, and June of $27 per peta hash per day. Wild. I mean, we know that theoretically hash price trades in backwardations, always gonna be going down on a long timeline. 5:04 We just didn't want it to go down that fast. So anyway, here we are, 38 bucks per peta hash per day. You thought this was an AI show. No, today's, today we're gonna kick it off with a little Bitcoin content. 5:16 Um, the next difficulty adjustment is August 22nd, which is tomorrow, and it's anticipated to be what? Basically flat, down 1%, so basically negligible. Um, 5:34 there's not a whole lot going on on-chain. There's not a lot of fees. Not a lot really happening, like, in Bitcoin land except the price is up. Thank you, Secretary Scott Bessent. 5:46 S- uh, scroll down really quickly to the forward chart, uh, 'cause I think this is interesting. This is interesting. The futures forward markets are already absorbing this move. 5:55 The, uh, so this is for hash rate forwards, i.e. futures. They're just not traded on an exchange, hence why they're called forwards. And this is the s- uh, average expected settlement price according to the contracts 6:10 On Luxur's forwards, they go six months out. You can see right now that the August spot price or the August, um, forward price is at $38.63 per peta hash per day and, uh, basically the same for September. 6:24 And even as far out as January, we have it above 35, $35.75 per peta hash per day, and it, it kind of tapers down throughout the year. But interesting to see that traders are already absorbing this. 6:36 Last thing I wanna focus on, Charlie, is, uh, hash rate here. Um, you know, it's, it's w- this is, you know, early innings with this rally, like it's kind of just kicked off. But if we go ahead and, like, look at the... 6:48 Let's look at the one month here. Um, it's been going up over the last month or so, and it's dipped down over the last week. Um, y- you can kind of see there's this resistance at about 950 exahashes. That really isn't... 7:03 It's not clearing that. So I would be curious, over the next week or so, what do we see in terms of hash rate recovery? Will some of those mar- uh, marginal machines come back online? Will, uh, uh... 7:15 Is there any capacity waiting in the wings to even be booted back up to make, uh, to, to, to capitalize on this opportunity of Bitcoin ripping and hash price going up? Yeah. 7:24 We've, we've been on a secular hash, hash rate, to- total network hash rate decline since November 9th, 2025. It has been, been losing 50, uh, exahash a month, maybe 20 exahash a month on average. 7:39 So yeah, right now the 30, the smooth moving day average for hash rate is at 915 exahash after it blew through a zettahash last year, towards the end of last year. Um, maybe was that the bottom? 7:55 Uh, you know, has everybody fully finished rotating out of AI? And, uh, will... [laughs] I mean, it's like, 8:03 I feel like, uh, our viewers and, uh, everyone monitoring this just has whiplash because everyone has been rotating out of Bitcoin mining as fast as legally possible in the, in the- Yeah... publicly traded markets. 100%. 8:16 And if that was... Yeah. If it's, if we're so back, um, I made this point, actually. I was... 8:21 I made this point last week, I think, talking about IONIQ and think, and talking about Bitdeer and, like, power pipelines, about how, um, it's not as the bad thing that miners, uh, pivoted to AI, but now they're locked in. 8:41 Their power is locked into big delivered AI HPC builds, and that is something it's, it's... 8:48 While it's logistically easier to build, to stand up a Bitcoin mine, uh, contractually, it's gonna be nearly impossible to do that in the USA. 8:58 So I don't see a future where Bitcoin mining rapidly expands Unit- in the USA considering that ever... 9:05 That you're just gonna be, that you're just locking giant power flaws into AI HPC deals, uh, which are on 10, 15, 20 year terms. So I think this is a structural, uh, structural bottleneck, at least in North America. 9:23 Yeah, I would agree with that. Unless the s- you know, the, uh, anti-data center hordes end up tearing down the walls of the data centers like Jericho, and there's no way to build them anymore. 9:33 They're, they're gonna walk around them seven times and then, uh- Yeah... tear down the sound barrier. [laughs] The sound barrier will fall when a Trump sounds. [laughs] Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Ah. [laughs] Uh, 9:45 but yeah, so I... 9:46 That's one thing I'd be keeping an eye on over the next week or so, is like t- we'll get an idea of how much hash rate is just sitting idle, but waiting for this opportunity based on what happens to hash rate o- on the seven-day moving average. 10:01 So- Yeah... I, I like, but I agree with you. I don't think we're gonna see probably w- like, we're gonna see some movement, no doubt. 10:09 It would not be as exaggerated as it would be, I think, if this were a different regime where data centers and AI weren't kind of taking up all the megawatts in the US. It really is like the... 10:20 It's, it, it really is the, the Bitcoin miner's trilemma, which is you have access to capital, access to powered land, or access to machines. And we have seen rotate through capital. 10:32 N- uh, capital is, um, it's not abundant, but it's accessible. Machines are the most liquid. They're cheap. They're f- The people are trying to give them to you right now. Good luck getting any powered land for this. 10:46 Good luck getting a PPA, uh, right now, uh, and outbidding the other AI HPC. So, like we, you know, 10:56 I'm h- there's your little catnip, your Bitcoin catnip, like structural supply deficit of, uh, where you can plug your machines in, so. Well, I think that does it, Charlie. Yeah, let's do... Okay. 11:09 So let's toss it to you. Um, let's say the magic words, Keel, Keel, Keel. Get the, the people all up in a tizzy. Yeah, for sure. Before that, uh, let's run our CleanSpark ad. Yeah. And we'll get into Keel. 11:24 [gentle music] We are CleanSpark, America's Bitcoin miner, a publicly traded company with the largest operating hash rate, powered entirely by self-operated infrastructure across four states. 11:41 This is our proof of work. We are setting the standard for what's next. Learn more about the intersection of energy and Bitcoin at cleanspark.com. All righty, so you'd think, 12:00 or maybe you wouldn't think, 12:03 that the companies under the boot of this new executive order would be upset about it, but Keel actually coming out with a press release yesterday in full support of Governor Josh Shapiro's data center executive order that places a number of new regulatory requirements on data centers being built in the state. 12:25 This is the headline coming to y'all from Blockspace. Keel says Pennsylvania data center rules will not delay Panther Creek or Sharon. And not just that, but they are supportive of what they are calling, uh, you know, 12:40 uh, what they are calling setting a highest, the highest bar in the country for the industry. 12:46 CEO Ben Gagnon said Keel supports the policy because its Pennsylvania development model already incorporates the state's requirements. 12:52 Quote, "Pennsylvania is setting the highest bar in the country for this industry, and we intend to clear it at Panther Creek, at Sharon, and at every project we build in the Commonwealth, including Scrubgrass." 13:04 Before we kind of get further into this, I do wanna just flag a comment from our listeners here. This is from The Don Killum. 13:13 "Will the new executive order in Pennsylvania, with the new executive order in Pennsylvania, how do you think Scrubgrass will be affected?" 13:19 My, my honest answer is I honest- I, I don't think that in terms of permitting and zoning, um, it will m- impact it that much. Scrubgrass was a while out anyway. It's currently under its power study. 13:34 They haven't even gone forward with the local permitting or zoning. So it might extend the timeline a little bit, I don't know. 13:42 But just judging based on, like, what they've done with Sharon and Panther Creek and the fact that they were already mo- more or less compliant with some of the new regulations before this happened, I don't think it'll materially impact it. 13:54 The only thing that is a little bit hairy, I think, a- and for all of the, the Keel's portfolio and for any company there are these clean energy requirements. They have to draw... 14:05 Uh, their energy mix has to comprise of 10% clean energy by 2027, uh, 14 and a half clean ener- percent clean energy by 2030, and then 32% of clean energy by 2035. 14:17 So that is a kind of a hurdle in, in with regards to making sure that they're sourcing generation from clean sources. 14:25 Uh, the, the only other thing I will say as well is the incremental energy arrangement, where now these data centers have to source energy from, from incremental generating sources, basically anything that was built after January 1st, 2025, and is not currently factored into the grid mix. 14:43 Uh, and in terms of, uh, generating capacity for other rate users, uh, or end rate users, I think that that's another thing that, you know, will just cause more headaches. 14:52 I don't think that it will materially derail any of these projects though. So going back to this story, uh, vis-a-vis Keel. 15:03 [lips smack] In the press release, they said that, again, the Panther Creek and the Sharon projects, uh, will not be affected by the, by these rules. They already have zoning and permitting for them. 15:16 Panther Creek has 350 megawatts of secured utility capacity with the utility PPL, formerly Pennsylvania, um, Power and Light, Lighting. 15:26 Zoning approval is a conditional land development approval for Panther Creek as well, though final environmental permits remain outstanding. 15:32 Sharon has zoning and land development approvals with Keel considering a combined 110 megawatt initial build there, while environ- environmental clearance remains pending. 15:40 So they just have to get those environmental permits squared away. But they already have the local zoning, and part of this executive order, the government in Pennsylvania is saying now you can't do things in parallel. 15:53 You can't do the local zoning and the state zoning and permitting at the same time. 15:57 You have to get the local and state zoning done first before you can get the state permitting done, and they've already gotten that local zoning from the, for Sharon and for Panther Creek. 16:09 It's also going back to that question that we just got. That's why I don't think that the, that Scrubgrass is necessarily threatened by this. 16:16 Since they know that they're gonna have to get that local zoning and permitting done first, they're going to tackle that before they can go on the state level. 16:23 Now that they have advanced notice, they're probably going to... Once they get the load, uh, the power study done and can secure that block of power, they'll just move first on that, so. 16:33 A few other things here with regards to these builds. Uh, Keel said that it pays the interconnection, transmission, distribution, and network upgrade costs attributal, attributable to its load. 16:44 The developer also said it engages municipalities before filing permits and discloses project footprints, load estimates, and water assumptions before major designs. 16:53 They plan to use closed loop cooling, quote, "to limit annual water consumption to the equivalent of a few dozen households," end quote. 17:00 So if you're looking for a little talking point there for your friends who think that these things are going to drink up all of the rivers, if they think that the Susquehanna is going to run dry because of data centers coming into Pennsylvania, you can point to that. 17:14 If they're using closed loop, the water footprint is minimal. 17:18 They said that sites will create hundreds of construction and operating jobs, and Keel's press r- press release also said, quote, "To ensure communities are equipped to meet this labor demand, Keel is working in close partnership with local educational institutions to develop and fund scholarship programs focused on data center construction and operating skills," end quote. 17:38 Uh, Keel has already done a s- a, a decent amount of community outreach in these areas. They have funded a playground, uh, in the locality near Panther Creek, for example. 17:48 That scholarship fund, I think, I don't know how much they're gonna commit to it. 17:51 That to me, though, is the kind of community engagement and public relations that is probably best for these data center companies to pursue rather than, as we covered on the stream this week, Charlie, right, that Oklahoma, uh, county commissioner's office where Google was trying to sweeten the deal for a data center there. 18:11 They offered to give them, like, a blank check for 200... Well, not a blank check. They offered to give them a $250,000 check, which is, like, equal to their annual budget, and he turned it down. 18:19 And I do think that there is a failure to mentally model Middle America for some of these tech companies, especially one as big as Google. 18:26 That guy's gonna look at that as a bribe, and instead of just giving them money, they would rather use... 18:32 They'd probably rather These companies invest in local infrastructure or recreation for the community, like things that are actually aligned with the community values. You're right, and I, I hear what you're saying. 18:47 I, I agree that, um, if you... For those viewers, we had a little segment, um, yesterday on Google having a data center in Oklahoma, and, uh, 18:59 and them basically dono- uh, offering to donate more than the entire annual budget of a volunteer department, volunteer fire department, too. 19:09 A- and the head of the fire department, the volunteer fire department, said he had to refuse it because it would look really bad. And yes, you can s- you can call that a bribe. It really becomes a semantics thing. 19:20 Is, like, where does, where, where does Google write the check? Where do they give back to the community? Do they do it entirely through, uh, tax structures? 19:29 Um, I'm actually preparing, uh, to, on Monday, do a deep dive into a particular state question here in Oklahoma regarding tax rebate and tax deferment for property tax, of which Google is a third of the entire state's tax rebate program, and we're voting on it on Tuesday. 19:49 And so, um, when, whene- I think you have multiple things here. 19:54 One, you have Middle America's failure of, to, uh, model the possi- the possibility that they might be wrong and in histrionics about things like water, and you have big tech's failure to model the reality that they have lo- they have no goodwill whatsoever on the ground among everybody at every single social class and ideology, and you have progressives' failure and inability to model the mind of someone who is not a coastal, uh, social elite. 20:28 So, a bunch of people, uh, this is, like, downstream of the, the world technology has created for us, so. Yeah, of a fractured political climate, too. I mean, it is- Yeah... 20:40 kind of interesting that the country's inability to comprehend each other is kind of crystallizing in this, what's becoming, for the elections, a load-bearing issue, which Load-bearing issue- Yeah... 20:53 the physical manifestation of technology in your backyard. Yeah. It's, it's wild because this has been, it's almost been entirely intangible. 20:59 Even, like, COVID, something which, like, you couldn't touch, you couldn't see. 21:03 Um, but now you have, we're erecting these, you know, uh, giant structures that you can drive past, and it's the physical manifestation of it. Is there anything else we wanna talk about, about the Pennsylvania deal? 21:16 Okay. Nope. Without further ado, we're gonna roll on to sub, uh, uh, in a story about who else? Leopold Aschenbrenner, the AI wunderkind, after a word from our sponsor, Luxor. 21:31 [fire crackles] This episode of Blockspace Live is brought to you by Luxor's Commander, Bitcoin miner management software for enterprise operations. 21:44 Luxor's Commander gives you real-time fleet monitoring, bulk remote commands across your fleet, and Intelligent Miner. 21:50 That's an automated profitability engine that runs every five minutes and adjusts your fleet's power settings against live hash rate and energy markets. 21:58 In fact, ERCOT backtests show 10% improved profitability with intelligent mining versus binary mining. 22:04 Commander Pro is roughly half the cost of competition, about $100 per megawatt, or a 25 basis point pool fee adder, but you can also try it free for 60 days. So if you'd like to learn more, go to luxor.tech/commander. 22:18 All right, this morning, hot off the presses here at Blockspace, Citadel unwinds more than 80% of risk acquired from Situational Awareness. Citadel, 22:31 of Ken Griffin's Citadel, has unwound more than 80% of the aggregate risk from the portfolio it acquired from Situational Awareness, headed by Leopold Aschenbrenner, according to a Friday client letter, 22:44 uh, from founder, CEO, founder and CEO Ken Griffin. They executed over 100 block trades representing over $4 billion in market value. 22:55 Citadel did not identify which securities traded, their sale prices, or the exposure that's still on the books. 23:03 The disclosure provides the first broad measure of how quickly Citadel reduced the risk acquired from Leopold Aschenbrenner's AI-focused hedge fund. 23:12 The figure refers to aggregate risk rather than the percentage of assets sold, so it does not establish the remaining portfolio's market value. Really interesting here. 23:22 Doesn't mean they sold off 80% of the notional value. They just de-risked 80% of the portfolio. So we don't know exactly what that means. Um, what do you... So what, what, what kind of risk was on the portfolio, Colin? 23:37 [laughs] Well, one of the reasons Leopold had been so successful is 'cause boy was just leveraged to the tits, at least for a billion-dollar hedge fund. Um, he was levered 400% across all positions. 23:53 Um, and while this did result in the per- fund's performance up 48% quarter over quarter, a snapshot of the last positioning filed weeks after the portfolio had collapsed, according to Melvin here, 24:09 showed that more than 55% of Leopold's situatio- situational awareness' book sat in two memory chip names: SanDisk and Micron. And so if you've been paying attention, you would know that 24:26 when did the Korea memory trade start unwinding? Late June and July. We covered this on the show, by the way, every step of this. 24:35 Um, and the remaining of the, the remainder of the bet was in names you might be familiar, Bloom Energy, TSMC, Nbius, CoreWeave, et cetera, Core Scientific, Airen. 24:46 Applied- I've, I've got some of the, uh, the long positions here Yeah. So what are... Yeah, pull it up So Sandisk at 5.67 billion is how much the, the exposure they had. Micron at 5.57 billion. 24:58 Bloom Energy at 1.9 billion. Taiwan Semiconductors, TSMC, um, at 1.27 billion. Nbius at 1.23 billion. CoreWeave, 744.5 million. Core Scientific, 665.6 million. 25:15 STM Electronics, 200- 584.3 million. Applied Digital, 469 million. And Riot, Riot Platforms, at 468.2 million. 25:28 And I'm, I'm, uh, consulting the chat, uh, the chat bot gods, or as my dad's friend likes to call it, Chat GTP- [laughs]... 25:37 uh, to see how much those positions have changed, because Citadel bought these at a discount, and then once the news hit, they just ripped, brother. Yeah. 25:49 [laughs] Well, they ripped and they sold, they, I mean, they sold or de-risked whatever the positions, whatever that means, 'cause they're sitting on 20% of the risk. Um, they probably still own many of these companies. 26:00 And- They probably still own many of it, and when they de-risked, I would imagine they, they, you know, took a, uh, pretty nice chunk of gains out of them. So for instance, since the July 30th close when, uh, when, 26:16 after July 30th close, um, the day that the Citadel purchased the stake, 26:21 uh, Sandisk is up 25%, Micron's up 11.4%, Bloom is down 2.2%, TSMC up 3.1%, Nbius up 18.8%, CoreWeave up 21.5%, Core Sci down 14.2%, STM Electronics down 5.9%, Applied Digital up 2.4, Riot down 9.4. 26:44 And, and so why would Ken want to still hold these assets? Because these things took a haircut, Ken bought 'em. Uh, s- some of them dipped further, but overall they r- they ri- overall, they ripped. 26:56 Um, Citadel having the best performance it's had in since 2022 in the month of June, um, I think a 5% return in June. 27:08 Um, and then on August 11th, roughly two weeks after absorbing Asher Burner's distess- distressed portfolio, Citadel Securities derivatives strategy head, Scott Rubner, published a note telling clients the leverage reset had largely run its course, and that systemic buyers were preparing to reload on the exact type of high beta semiconductor names that had just been liquidated, citing leveraged ETF assets crashing 42% and semiconductor leveraged ETF's shrink- shrinking to just 31 billion. 27:43 Then this week, Citadel disclosed Cidi- uh, Griff- Ken Griffin disclosed that Citadel had already shed more than 80% of that risk through over 100 block trades worth more than four billion. So basically, 27:58 who eats at the end of the day? Ken Griffin. Leopold was too levered. 28:04 Uh, we really can attribute the main body floating to the surface of the Korea crash and the pullback in the late June as it was Leopold just levered, levered up too big. 28:15 So Ken Griffin comes in and says, "I believe in the trade. Everyone else believes in the trade. We just had to de-leverage someone." Can, can I just say the boomers are having a field day with this one? Oh my God. 28:27 I mean, th- this is emblematic of the boomer versus Gen Z/Millennial culture war. You know, this, this, this young, a- as you called him, this, this wunderkind trader- Whippersnapper [laughs]... 28:41 come, comes out of OpenAI, this whippersnapper comes out, and he is just y- yoloing, honestly kind of just de-genning into these positions with super high leverage and blowing every other fund out of the water. 28:55 But Ken Griffin, like a shark in the shallows, waiting for the second blood is drawn and then snaps it all up. You- I have to- Yeah. I mean- [laughs] Go ahead. 29:07 I have to actually say both are right, because Leopold literally wrote the book on this trade, and he identified it incredibly precisely, and he bet with conviction, and he bet in the right things. 29:20 However, his execution, uh, was way too presumptuous and over his skis. 29:25 If you do the math, I saw some, I saw some commentators doing the math, and it, and it implies that Leopold at times was 20 to 25% of the entire trading volume or position in some of these, uh, companies. 29:40 Um, which I think the rule is like you never wanna be over 5%. 29:44 So it's like very obvious things that you realize if you are 25% of this, of like the circulating supply or trading volume, even for some of these, uh, companies, like you are just s- you're, you're, you're so overexposed, and why would you even be doing that on leverage? 30:01 So, um, yeah, I think, I think everybody's gonna learn the wrong lesson here. One, the boomer, you know, the boomers are gonna laugh and say, "Ha ha, you dumb kids trying to bet on disruptive technology." 30:12 And then, uh, and then the kids are gonna say, "Ah, the boomers are actually here to destroy us." And I think that neither is really true. You have to be both right and you have to have right execution. 30:24 And- I mean, I think and that's, that's kind of my point in all of this- Yeah... is like there were some boomers who were saying like, "None of this stuff makes sense," and they're wrong. 30:32 I mean, Ken Griffin obviously- They're wrong... obviously thinks that it does make sense. Yeah. But the difference in experience, right? 30:39 You have like a 24-year-old, 25 now I guess, running this book, and he has no, he- no risk management. Like, clearly zero risk management. 30:48 Or if there was risk management, it was like trying to, you know, w- uh, use y- I don't know, like wood chips for the foundation of a house. Or like, you know, like- Yeah... 30:59 your firewall is like actually just plastic bags or something. Yeah. Um, 31:04 ultimately he didn't have the risk management in place, and a seasoned trader and investor like Ken Griffin is the guy who is going to eat your lunch when you leave it out in the open, right? 31:17 And so- Ken Griffin should just hire Leopold, uh, because you take Leopold's wunderkind visionary, uh, insights and his, uh, insanely deep Rolodex, which we all know is the real secret, um, and then you just take Citadel's ruthless perfect execution. 31:38 Uh, um, so I think Leopold's gonna get a second chance. 31:41 I mean, word around the valley from my tertiary sources on Twitter suggest that Leopold was going around and passing the hat around, and that, um, everyone who had invested in the fund, um, basically up until late spring, was pretty happy actually. 31:57 So- Yeah, I think I saw a take where it's like, you know, he made billions of dollars on this book. Um, he's going to probably raise money again. Yeah. Even if it blew up once. 32:07 And it's not like he scammed any- there's a difference here. Yeah. 'Cause it's not like he scammed people, and it was like the largest notional value loss of a fund, I think, in history, um, like this quickly. 32:17 No, he didn't scam anyone. He was just- But he did scam everybody... stupid and stupid. Yeah. Like, you, you, you have to have risk management in place if you're doing this, right? Yeah. So who among us, though, [laughs] 32:28 who among us has not gotten caught off sides with, uh, you know, presumptuous leverage at the tender age of 24, leading into your wedding, mind you, by the way. 32:38 I, I thought that was like a rumor or a joke that he was actually getting married the weekend that he got liquidated, but it was not. He actually did have his wedding that Saturday [laughs] after he got liquidated. 32:51 Okay, um, enough about Leopold. I think we're gonna, uh, talk about data centers for a little bit. But before we do data centers, a word from our sponsor, Ligos. 33:01 [static sound] Bitcoin is ripping and eyeing $80,000 for the first time since May. But don't get complacent. If you're using a Bitcoin-backed lender, you need to ask yourself the question, do they really have your coins? 33:19 Do you know where your coins are? Well, with Ligos Finance, you don't have to worry about that question. 33:25 Ligos Finance is our preferred Bitcoin-backed lender here at Blockspace, and they use Bitcoin-native smart contracts to make sure you always control the keys to your coins. You heard that right. 33:35 With Ligos Finance, your Bitcoin never leaves your self-custody. There's no bridging, no rehypothecation, no wrapping, no funny business, just competitive rates as low as 8.5 to 10% APR. 33:48 Go to ligos.finance to learn more. All right, headlines this morning, maybe yesterday, from Axios, "Exclusive: GOP issues stark warning to AI companies." What does that- Did you say GOP? 34:05 [laughs] Yeah. You, no, you, you, people call it GOP. People absolutely call it GOP. Eh. [laughs] Oh my God. Okay. Well, we're gonna have to argue about this. I've been hearing people... I've... 34:17 Okay, the GOP, the Grand Old Party, [laughs] issues stark warning to AI companies, um, basically saying that the people hate you. And more narrowly, 34:32 GOP could cost, data centers could cost GOP, G-O-P, a Senate seat in Ohio, Republicans warn. What's going on here? I thought the GOP was super pro-business. No. 34:49 Everyone has caught up to what we've been talking about for months, which is on the ground, your neighbors in your rural counties and your coastal cities and in your wealthy states and wealthy cities, everyone hates data centers, and they are furious about it. 35:08 Um, and, uh, in one of the like ground zeros for industrial revitalization and data center build-outs, especially for hyperscalers, Ohio, you have a very hotly contested seat. 35:21 In particular, JDan Husted, the incumbent, uh, senator, and Sherrod Brown, who formerly incumbent senator, are in a dead heat. Private polling, quote from the story on [clears throat] Axios, "Has been consistent. 35:39 When voters hear Brown's position and his record, Husted pulls away." This is still the path, that is still the path in this race. 35:48 The new ingredient, however, is data centers, and we have a clip to play here showing a good old-fashioned anti data center hit piece from Sherrod Brown on J.D. Husted. It's a campaign ad, mind you, everyone- Yeah... 36:05 who's listening and watching. He's been called the face of data centers in Ohio. Why? Because J.D. 36:11 Husted spent years aggressively recruiting data centers to the state, cutting sweetheart tax deals and fast-tracking approvals while ordinary residents watch their electricity bills explode. 36:24 We're here with Ohio Senator JD. Husted. He have a lot of experience with something called data centers. J.D. Husted: who's he really working for? I'm Sherrod Brown, and I approve this message. So- 36:39 I just wanna get it out in front that obviously I'm biased. I am a, uh, data center propagandist by trade. That being said, I, I remember Sherrod Brown during a lot of the anti-crypto movement stuff in 2021, 2022. 36:55 Yeah, we hated him. We, we lit- we put together the biggest pack, super PAC ever to get this guy out of office, and it worked. 37:01 Yeah, and so anyone in Bitcoin will remember that this guy, in numerous congressional testimonies, pushed falsehoods, fabricated, you know, narratives about, you know, 37:16 literally odd- the, the dumbest stuff that you could imagine about, like, you know, like what crypto is being used for like sex trafficking and money laundering and all this other stuff. 37:26 Um, obviously there is some money laundering that's used for cryptocurrencies, but like conveniently ignoring the idea that actually the dollar is the number one medium for money laundering in the world. 37:36 So like if that's the bar, then, you know, [chuckles] we can't even clear it with our own legal tender here in the United States. And, and I do... The, the campaign ad being a feature, 37:49 uh, making data centers a feature of the messaging is really notable here, and that's something that the memo points out. I wanna read a few quotes here from the memo, Charlie. Um, 38:00 quote, "Data centers are the centerpiece in the case Sherrod Brown is litigating. He has made them his de facto opponent, and no one is correcting the record. 38:10 Brown has put three unique television ads on air and spent millions doing it. 38:13 Our polling indicates that the message is significantly more effective than traditional messaging tracks as it introduces new information on a highly relevant emerging topic. 38:22 This has become a sleeper issue for the entire cycle. Campaigns or party committees cannot fix the topic, the, the toxic brand of an entire segment of the economy. 38:32 The companies that need these projects built have to fix how Ohioans are seeing them, who benefits, who pays, and why a community should want one. Until that happens, the issue will continue to dominate this race. 38:45 If it is still this potent in November, elected officials everywhere will treat Ohio as their reason to work against data centers in the future. 38:53 If voters' perceptions of data centers are not fixed quickly, the campaign against them will expand far beyond Ohio." Brother, it already has. Yeah. Where have you been? It's already here. 39:05 This is a Pandora's box thing, I think. And like they're right to say that if this works against Husted in Ohio, the template will be copy-pasted across all of these other races for the midterms. 39:18 Um, but- Oh, I absolutely think it will be p- copy-pasted. It's incredi- it's incredibly effective- Yeah... and it's like very unifying. I... 39:25 Yeah, this is a crisis moment if you are, uh, if you've been pro data centers in the past, regardless of party, but it's largely Republicans who are typically generally the pro-business people. Yeah. 39:38 One- 100%, and I, I do think, and we'll get to some commentary online about all of the different takes with regards to the data center pushback. 39:46 Uh, funnily enough, you know, I, I see a lot of people who are right-coded who like probably agree with data centers, but lending a sympathetic ear to why people don't want them. 39:57 Um, I- That's, I mean, that's probably me. Yeah. That's basically who I am, yeah. And it, it's me to an extent as well. Like, you know, I think about, 40:05 I think about folks that I know back in Tennessee, and if they told me why they wouldn't want one of these things, I would not dismiss them or scoff at them. 40:11 I would try to explain some of the benefits or like get to know why they don't like them. I do think that one of the, um... 40:18 Well, I'll, I'll get a tweet up on this in a moment, but there's kind of like there's the micro views and issues of environmentalism and resource use and aesthetics. 40:28 Then there's the macro views, and a lot of takes I've seen just point out the very simple fact that a lot of Silicon Valley and the coastal elites don't realize how much Middle America despises them. 40:40 Um, not only have they enriched themselves on a tech bubble that has continued for a few decades while everyone else's wages stagnate, but you've got guys like Dario Amodei talking about how AI is going to replace all the jobs and kill everyone, and that's why we need to regulate it. 40:57 Oh, and by the way, my wife tried to get money from Jeffrey Epstein for a porn company. So people see those things- [laughs]... and they don't, you know, these, these are not allies to them. 41:09 They, they, they don't even begin to understand why they do the things they do. They see them as threats. 41:14 And you have had all of these AI CEOs going out and talking about how actually, yeah, it's gonna replace a lot of jobs, it's gonna do all these things, you know, um, we'll probably have to have UPI to replace it. 41:25 And then by God, you just see Sam Altman talk. Like you just need to watch the guy talk, and he sounds like an alien to the average American. 41:35 The best thing Zuckerberg ever did was rebrand himself and make himself relatable overnight. Um, everyone else, they, they, they talk like, they literally talk like lizard people. 41:45 Like if you thought they might have lizards inside of their bodies, um, you just watch them for like t- 20 seconds, and you'd be like, oh yeah, they're... Sam Altman does have, uh, just glassy, empty eyeballs. 41:57 And, um, I mean, okay, so like they do tell you the story of like they're gonna take the jobs. That's not actually the main thing I see on the ground though, Colin. 42:06 In like my rural America window, the a- the, the jobs thing is kind of, it's a point. 42:13 It actually has to do more with the same zeitgeist that Middle America and, um, the conservatives out there, or just non-progressives, um, actually have the same, uh, I would say it's the same zeitgeist that I'll compare to, um, people who, uh, 42:31 wanted to post, uh, critical things about the government's response to COVID. Um, similar- Yeah... 42:39 how people would be like, "Well, I don't buy the pub- you know, the government's narrative," or, "I'm critical of certain government policies," or, "I'm structurally critical of the government's narrative of the origin of COVID," and then you get banned on social media. 42:53 You don't get, you, you're, you can't go, like you get fired from work 'cause you don't, uh, 'cause you're skeptical of the vaccine. 42:59 It's a very similar type because that type of person now sees, and you cannot understate this, the flock camera on every corner in their city, and they see that as the physical manifestation of the AI data center which is going to be built in their backyard. 43:16 And so that is why, that's actually the same, like the reason they are opposed to these things, and then they kinda like latch onto water as that's the way the l- the, the elites, the tech elites are gonna drain our resources and stuff like that. 43:29 Because they're, they're angry about farmland being taken over by data centers. They're angry about water, and they're angry about surveillance. 43:37 That's not really like the jobs thing, although that is a contributing factor. It's like- That's a really good, that's a really good point. It's actually one that I wanted to bring up with regards to this tweet from, 43:47 uh, Polymath here. I need to get yours down. Here we go. Polymath tweets here, quote, "In the last year, American tech companies have laid off 170,000 workers with the explicit claim that these cuts are due to AI. 44:01 Compare this to 1,547 new data center jobs." Uh, need an asterisk on that one. Gosh, I wonder why people have soured on data centers in the last 12 months. 44:11 I think this is a decent point, though I would counter it by saying there are different concerns for different populaces. 44:19 So like you said, the, the average rural American, quite frankly, isn't competing with AI for their job. 44:25 They're probably in a service economy where, uh, restaurants, trade jobs, et cetera, things of that nature are the bedrock of the local economy. They're not, as my friend calls them, doing beep boop jobs. No. 44:39 They don't have laptop jobs, right? So they're not- They don't care that, they don't care that, that everybody laid off all their engineers, 'cause they're like, "I don't know. I ain't got no friends who are engineers." 44:47 Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Uh, that being said though, I do think this tweet gets to the heart of why a lot of young folks, especially on the left, vehemently oppose this. 44:59 Uh, they went and got college degrees, are saddled with six figure student loan debt, and they entered into an anemic job market where their best prospect is working as a waiter or a manager of a restaurant or something of that nature. 45:14 Like they went to college and then they ended up in the service industry anyway, so they see AI as just another glass ceiling that they are going to have to slam their head against to try to get ahead after graduating. 45:26 And I do think that for that contingent, that, that is a part of the crux here. 45:32 It's like, "Why would I support this thing if all the people building it are saying that it's going to replace a job that I can't even get, and I have no hope of getting, especially if AI becomes the competition for that job?" 45:45 So. Yeah. You're a young person. You're told to go get into untold amounts of student debt, that you go and you're like, "Well, at least I'm gonna go be a software engineer." 45:55 And [laughs] then, then, uh, [laughs] and then that's the first thing to go. 46:00 Now, yes, there's this whole like other narrative of like the K-shaped software engineer economy and software developer, developer hirings on the rise, but yet I talk to a lot of my friends who like maybe did a late, you know, like they studied something else in college and they taught themselves like, uh, some, like self-taught software engineering, and to pivot into the more secure r- like, uh, uh, career and at the perfect wrong time. 46:28 I have multiple close friends who are actually in this exact situation. Um, and so they hate AI. They, they despise it. And, um, okay, a lot of people can say, "Well, you just gotta get good," but that's... 46:41 Imagine being told that and, and, and imagine you move to an expensive cost of living city, Austin, Dallas, Denver, growing cities, Miami. 46:50 These are, these are hot, you know, hot growing job markets for the, the young, uh, career-driven person, and now your career is an existential question, and you have a quarter million in debt. Like, man. 47:05 Student loan forgiveness and UBI might be on the table sooner rather than not, brother. That's, that's- I mean, Biden didn't do it. [laughs] It's... Well, Biden, you know, eh. Bi- bi- Yeah. 47:15 [laughs] Biden, uh- He probably forgot... he didn't know what he was doing. Yeah. Also, Biden just an absolute centrist, you know, kind of blob state candidate. Yeah. 47:23 But, um, I, I, I did wanna get this up too because just going back to like how unpopular this is becoming, this is from Robinson Meyer of Heatmap News. 47:34 I was pretty shocked at how much the goalposts have, or not goalposts, to how much the Overton window has shrunk here, Charlie. 47:42 Quote, "Over the past year we've asked Americans whether they would support or oppose a data center being built near where they live. We haven't changed the wording. 47:51 When we first polled the question a year ago, Americans were split 43 to 42 on support versus oppose. When we asked again in February, a bare majority opposed data centers. 48:02 Today 75% of Americans say they would oppose a data center being built near where they live, and 61% said they would, quote, 'strongly oppose,' end quote, such a proposal." That's an incredible attrition. 48:17 The fact that we went from this being a basically split ticket issue a year ago to now you're in the minority if you support these things at all is staggering to me. Uh, yeah. And, um, 48:34 I think a lot of people think that, "Oh, well, oh, Charlie, why are you so supportive of data centers? Don't you want one in your backyard?" I'm like, "No, I don't want one in my backyard. 48:42 I wouldn't be opposed to it outside of town, though." Um, what are the actual adverse effects that happen when a data center is built in your backyard? Um, it's actually still really unclear what those are. 48:55 I think the wor- the real worst thing, we talk about this all the time, is that, uh, you, you could have, um, a- A really asymmetric, uh, CapEx in- investment in your community without reaping commensurate rewards. 49:10 And then that filters into, uh, like cost of living, um, and home prices. I think those are very real issues as well as just the influx of people- Yeah... building this, this data center. But besides that, um, like 49:25 show me the data on how these actually d- changed, uh, your, that your life. Like electricity bill, water usage. 49:38 Um, this piece from Nick Carter, which is a little bit old now, I guess it's two or three months old, um, it shows empirically we don't see that data centers really affect your power bill, and this is due to a long explanation about how power rates get to the consumer and the end user. 49:57 Um, then you also have to consider, uh, 50:03 uh, you also have to consider water, which while it does sound like these things use a ton, millions of gallons of water, you have to c- look at that in, in context of everything else, and it, it is, it's, it's minimal really, and it's pretty negligible, especially with the emergence of closed loop, like circular systems that don't intake significantly new water. 50:25 Yeah, there was an El Paso Times article that we covered on Block Space recently where a meta data center is moving into the area, and they said they won't even be a top 10 consumer of water, and they're using, like 500,000 gallons per day. 50:40 So you know. What- Yeah. Um- What are we doing here, guys? And then there are... 50:46 And then a lot of this is also, uh, just s- just very complex and, uh, structural with regards to how the electrical grid works and who pays for different parts of it, and it's because the regulations and the way that who pays for expansion of the grid just cannot keep up with the speed of this build-out, that, um, you're, what we're going to see, and this is my prediction, is that while we haven't seen data centers materially move e- uh, electricity, electricity rates yet, 51:20 um, we could find ourselves in a scenario where they do dramatically impact electricity rates to the average person just because of, like how the costs are passed on, uh, and how the build-out goes, which is downstream of how the build-out can, can happen, uh, from a regulatory standpoint. 51:40 And this is, this gets into regional transmission operators and- And, and this is something-... like behind the meter and-... completely lost on the average- Yeah... on the average American. 51:49 Like they barely- It's complicated for me. Yeah, it's complicated for us. It's for me as well. 51:53 I mean, at the end of the day, these are incredibly complex systems, and most people don't even know where their generation or where their electricity is coming from, where it's being generated. Comes out of the plug. 52:05 Yeah. You know? Exactly. The water comes out of the faucet, and the electricity comes out of the plug. 52:09 But, you know, I think, uh, the, uh, the last little piece of information that I'll throw in here, Charlie, from the social media debate, which was... 52:18 Actually, I'll throw in two, because there's one that I just, I have to just have a quick aside on this one, 'cause I think it actually gets to the heart of, like how people view these things. Um, 52:31 this is from a journalist, an erstwhile or sometimes Atlantic contributor, Jasmine Sun. The data center backlash is a product of two mutually reinforcing dynamics, kind of like we talked about earlier. 52:41 Locally, it's material concerns, noise, water, electricity, and process failures, NDAs, tax subsidies. Two, nationally, it's broad anti-corporate and anti s- AI sentiment. 52:51 AI companies are screwing you over to get off, to g- to get rich off dumb toys. 52:56 Um, Jasmine might be just using dumb toys there to, like kind of use it as a pastiche of that position, but I think there are legitimate people who think like this, that these are just dumb toys. 53:06 And I think if you have that frame in mind, there's almost no way to talk about these things rationally. 53:12 Um, one of the most, like fundamentally transformative technologies that we've ever seen being labeled as a dumb toy, I don't know how to talk with a person like that, 'cause they're probably just not going to be convinced. 53:23 Also, on the tax subsidies part, part of the reason for that, the, these buildings are valued at billions of dollars. 53:34 So the reason why the tax, like they're getting a break on the percentage of how much they owe, because if they didn't, it might not be economically viable to operate. 53:43 I think that is really missing when we talk about tax breaks. Like, people assume that it's just, like giving these companies free money. 53:51 It's like, no, it's because if you had them at the normal property tax rate, they would be paying, like hundred, tens to hundreds of millions of dollars per year, depending on the size. 54:02 Hundreds Yeah, the average person doesn't realize- Some... 54:03 like if per, per square foot of, like these facilities, of the actual buildings, they're some, some of the most valuable installations and, like man-made creations of all time. Wild to say that out loud. 54:16 Um, I'll say on the other hand, complete waivers of tax liability for these is probably not the right decision. Oh, I, I agree with that 100%. 54:24 As Oklahoma currently pretty much does, and that's actually the subject of the vote next week. Again, I'll get into that next week. 54:33 But, a- a- and so, like this is why everyone needs to just get good and get agile and get on their toes, because, like now's the time to make money, and then to also avoid making the wrong decision. 54:46 So you have to act quickly. Um, and here's an example of what you can benefit if you act quickly. Here's this tweet from Cremier. Um, this is a fun exercise. 54:58 How large a data center would you, would you need in your town to replace your property taxes? In 2023, US local governments collected $1,965 per resident in property taxes. 55:10 So for a 20,000 person town, let's say a small rural America town, that nets out 39.3 million in annual revenue. Let's be conservative, call it 40. Let's combine, uh, every relevant service. 55:23 Um, commercial effective property tax rates in major US cities are typically in the range of one to 3%, so let's just call it 2%. 55:30 So that means our annual property tax being 40 million would need a taxable value of $2 billion. 55:38 If we run the math on a $2 billion data center, investment would look like, ballpark at $10 million per megawatt build-out, that's a 200 megawatt data center. Um, 55:52 that's if all the construction were taxable, including the, the heaviest part of the CapEx, which is the GPUs. Um, so in short, if you wanna be very hand-wavy, 56:04 if you had a 20,000 person town in rural America at a standard, like assessed value tax rate of 2%, you could generate enough tax revenue to waive all property taxes for your community. 56:18 And I think that should probably be a good finger in the wind goal, and that is the giant carrot on the stick for your community. Uh, and wouldn't you just love to get rid of your property taxes? 56:30 Yeah, or even lower them, right? Lower them, yeah. 56:32 Even if you're not gonna get rid of them, if you could cut, especially for some of these areas that have seen rapid home price appreciation, that could be very meaningful. 56:40 I mean, West Virginia is trying to do this to eliminate their, uh, state tax. Yeah, and that's the gentrification. 56:46 That's the gentrification of property value, and that's one of the things I keep going back to of like that's one of the big risks, and that's the, one of the like intractable problems of this mass investment coming into community is that prices people out from owning their home that you rent from the government. 57:01 So- Yeah, that's actually a, uh, an argument that we haven't seen much of, and I think is kind of more understandable than others for being a little leery here. 57:11 Last thing I wanted to bring up, Charlie, and then we can maybe wrap. Yeah. Uh, this is coming from Josh Zofer, um, an investor, and he cites 57:22 that fewer than 20% of Americans use AI daily in any context, including work, poor- per Stanford's Digital Economy Lab. 57:32 Even among those daily users, few are the kind of power users you usually find in San Francisco or on X, with access to large token budgets and true frontier models. 57:40 If you talk to employees at Fortune 500 companies, an astonishingly large share only, still only have Copilot. 57:47 Uh, and by contrast, he says here, according to Pew, 38% of Americans live within five miles of an operational data center. I find that a little hard to believe, unless you're just pulling from cities. 57:59 Um, that, I don't know about that one. That being said, though, he's basically making the point here that like there's not enough penetration here. 58:06 People don't see that the, they don't see any benefits to AI in their daily lives, something that we actually talked about when we were discussing the Josh Shapiro, uh, executive order. 58:18 And he also says here, quote, "AI will cu- cure cancer," end quote, is far less likely to resonate with people who aren't using frontier products. I, you know, 58:28 I, I get, I get where he's coming from because they don't understand the capabilities. But honestly, man, like if you can't make the case that we'll have medical breakthroughs 58:38 with this technology and that doesn't resonate with people, I'm kind of black pilled on whether or not this will ever actually go any place constructive. I, 58:47 I, I just, i- if you can't tell people that otherwise incurable diseases will probably have breakthroughs in the next 10 years because of d- uh, because of machine learning, then, uh, you know, I don't know. 59:00 I don't know- Uh, well, the break- the breakthroughs allow you to f- uh, fire more employees, basically. [laughs] I mean, is that really the breakthrough you wanna preach? 59:09 Um, yeah, it'll make society more productive, but the K shape gets more K like over time. Anyway, that's our show for today. Thank you for watching Blockspace live stream this week. 59:22 We do this every weekday at 1:00 PM Eastern. We are Compute's daily live show featuring quick hits on AI, data centers, markets, and emerging technology. 59:32 If you missed the live stream, it turns into a podcast shortly after we wrap. You can find that anywhere podcasts are streamed, Spotify, Apple, and RSS enabled products. If you want more, blockspace.media is the website. 59:47 We have a newsletter. We have more written content. That's blockspace.media. This show is brought to you by CleanSpark, NASDAQ listed ticker CLSK. I'm Charlie. I'm Colin. We'll see ya on Monday. 1:00:01 [upbeat music]